Pink slime journalism refers to organizations that masquerade as local news outlets, often publishing articles that serve special interests. Past research and reporting has illuminated the production of pink slime journalism (e.g., identifying pink slime outlets and documenting their practices), but no work has systematically analyzed the consumption of pink slime. In this paper, we combine web browsing behavior of a nationally representative sample of American adults collected during the 2020 election (N = 1,238; 21 million website visits) with a database of websites of pink slime outlets (1,627 outlets, 132,237 distinct articles) to illuminate who, what, when, where, and why in the consumption of pink slime journalism. Our analysis reveals that 3.7% of American adults (approximately 9.5 million people) visited pink slime in the months surrounding the 2020 election. Pink slime consumption differed considerably from consumption of both misinformation and traditional local news websites. We also find mismatch between production and consumption, with the topics of produced and promoted pink slime articles differing greatly from the topics of articles consumed. Google and Facebook were prominent referrers to pink slime. Despite speculation, people in news deserts were not more likely to be exposed to pink slime.
29 November 2023 in Social Science Computer Review
Social scientists and computer scientists are increasingly using observational digital trace data and analyzing these data post hoc to understand the content people are exposed to online. However, these content collection efforts may be systematically biased when the entirety of the data cannot be captured retroactively. We call this often unstated assumption the problematic assumption of accessibility. To examine the extent to which this assumption may be problematic, we identify 107k hard news and misinformation web pages visited by a representative panel of 1,238 American adults and record the degree to which the web pages individuals visited were accessible via successful web scrapes or inaccessible via unsuccessful scrapes. While we find that the URLs collected are largely accessible and with unrestricted content, we find there are systematic biases in which URLs are restricted, return an error, or are inaccessible. For example, conservative misinformation URLs are more likely to be inaccessible than other types of misinformation. We suggest how social scientists should capture and report digital trace and web scraping data.
In this multi-platform, comparative study, we analyze social media messages from political candidates ( N = 1,517) running for Congress during the 2022 U.S. Midterm election. We collect data from seven social media platforms: Facebook, Twitter, Truth Social, Gettr, Instagram, YouTube, and Rumble over the 4 weeks before and after election day. With this unique dataset of posts, we apply computational methods to identify messages that sought to mobilize individuals (online and offline) to donate money, vote, attend events, engage with the campaign online, and visit the campaign’s content on other platforms. We find that Democrats were not on alt-tech platforms in 2022 and that both Republicans and Democrats use video-based platforms for multiple mobilization strategies. Mobilization messages varied for House and Senate candidates of both parties across platforms, before and after election day.
28 May 2024 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Social media’s pivotal role in catalyzing social movements is widely acknowledged across scientific disciplines. Past research has predominantly explored social media’s ability to instigate initial mobilization while leaving the question of its capacity to sustain these movements relatively uncharted. This study investigates the persistence of movement activity on Twitter and Gab following a substantial on-the-ground mobilization event catalyzed by social media—the StoptheSteal movement culminating in the January 6th Capitol attack. Our findings indicate that the online communities active in the January 6 mobilization did not display substantial remobilization in the subsequent year. These results highlight the fact that further exploration is needed to understand the factors shaping how and when movements are sustained by social media. In this regard, our study provides valuable insights for scientists across diverse disciplines, on how certain social media platforms may contribute to the evolving dynamics of collective action.
The proliferation of misinformation, especially during critical periods such as election seasons, challenges democratic processes worldwide. Combining a two-wave panel study with web-browsing behavior (N = 21M) of 1,194 American adults around the 2020 U.S. Presidential Election, we find that those exposed to at least one misinformation website are 17.3% more likely to believe that the election was fraudulent in a post-election survey. However, one challenge in assessing the effects of misinformation is disentangling the behavior of individuals selectively exposing themselves to misinformation congenial to an existing belief versus prior political identities heterogeneously leading to differing effects on beliefs. To disentangle selective exposure from motivated reasoning, we apply a causal machine learning method that controls for the propensity to be exposed to a misinformation website. Using this approach, we quantify the association between exposure to misinformation websites and false election beliefs. Using this method, we find exposure to misinformation is associated with the likelihood of false election beliefs by 4.2%. This effect, however, is asymmetric and consistent with a motivated reasoning account: for conservatives, whose candidate lost the election, the association is 12.6%, while for liberals, the association is negligible at -0.2%. Further, we identify a dosage effect, where each additional exposure to misinformation websites increases the association between misinformation website exposure and false election beliefs among conservatives by .035% but only .010% for liberals. These findings contribute to our understanding of misinformation's real-world effects, demonstrating a significant impact on election validity beliefs that vary by political orientation and exposure frequency. Our results underscore the importance of addressing misinformation not as a uniform influence but as a factor whose effects are contingent upon individual predispositions and exposure volume.
8 November 2023 in Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication
Extensive research reveals gender gaps in social media expression, particularly women’s reduced propensity for sharing political information and opinions. We examine the impact of political defeat on the gender gap in political expression on social media by pairing Twitter data from candidate supporters with a voter file. Our results indicate that Trump’s 2020 defeat reduced tweet volumes only among his female supporters, while his male supporters remained unaffected. This dampening effect was stronger for female Trump supporters who expressed their gender identity in their Twitter bios than those who did not. Tweet content remained largely unchanged for both genders. These findings enhance our understanding of how social media and political defeat together contribute to the gender expression gap and its relationship with offline political behaviors post-defeat. They also demonstrate the power of our methodological approach in revealing temporal and individual differences.