Mexican papaya (Carica papaya L.) orchards are dedicated to national and international markets, producing 1,142,854 tons annually, 17% of which are exported. Tetranychus merganser Boudreaux and Tetranychus urticae Koch (Acari: Tetranychidae) are recurrent pest mites in papaya. Both species have the potential to reduce photosynthesis, with severe damage resulting in yield reductions of 33-45% due to defoliation and loss of commercial quality in sun-damaged fruits. One alternative for controlling these pests is using predatory mites such as Galendromus floridanus Muma (Acari: Phytoseiidae). Although this species has been reported on papaya, its capacity to consume these pest mites has not yet been studied. This research aimed to evaluate the preference and consumption capacity of G. floridanus for different developmental stages of T. merganser and T. urticae, using experimental arenas and papaya plants in a laboratory setting. In both methods, 10 individuals of each developmental stage of the pest mites were offered; however, in the plant method, eggs were not included because newly laid eggs by adult females in any part of the plant might yield an erroneous count. Prey consumption was recorded at various time intervals: 2, 4, 6, 12, and 24 h for experimental arenas and 1, 2, and 24 h for plants. The Manly preference index was calculated for both prey species. The search, capture, and prey-handling behaviors were observed during day and night hours. Female G. floridanus consumed all developmental stages of both prey species. In experimental arenas, females showed a preference for consuming eggs and larvae. However, the predator consumed more larvae on plants where the egg stage was not provided. Adults were the least preferred stage in both methods. The highest predatory activity was observed during the first 12 hours of the day, as female predators spent more time resting at night. G. floridanus can feed on all developmental stages of T. merganser and T. urticae, but it shows a clear preference for earlier developmental stages of both prey species. Thus, predators should be released in the mid to lower leaves, where veins meet, once mite infestations have started.