1 March 2024 in IEEE Access
While current automotive safety standards provide implicit guidance on how unreasonable risk can be avoided, manufacturers are required to specify risk acceptance criteria for Automated Driving Systems (SAE Level 3 and higher). However, the ‘unreasonable’ level of risk of Automated Driving Systems is not yet concisely defined. Solely applying current safety standards to such novel systems could potentially not be sufficient for their acceptance. As risk is managed with implicit knowledge about safety measures in existing automotive standards, an explicit alignment with risk acceptance criteria is challenging. Hence, we propose an approach for an explicit representation and management of risk, which we call the Risk Management Core. The proposal of this process framework is based on requirements elicited from current safety standards and is applied to the task of specifying safe behavior for an Automated Driving System in an example scenario.
8 November 2024 in IEEE Access
Automated vehicles in public traffic are subject to a number of expectations: Among other aspects, their behavior should be safe, conforming to the rules of the road and provide mobility to their users [1], [2]. This poses challenges for the developers of such systems: Developers are responsible for specifying this behavior, for example, in terms of requirements at system design time. As we will discuss in the article, this specification always involves the need for assumptions and trade-offs. As a result, insufficiencies in such a behavior specification can occur that can potentially lead to unsafe system behavior. In order to support the identification of specification insufficiencies, requirements and respective assumptions need to be made explicit. In this article, we propose the Semantic Norm Behavior Analysis as an ontology-based approach to specify the behavior for an Automated Driving System equipped vehicle. We use ontologies to formally represent specified behavior for a targeted operational environment, and to establish traceability between specified behavior and the addressed stakeholder needs. Furthermore, we illustrate the application of the Semantic Norm Behavior Analysis in a German legal context with two example scenarios and evaluate our results. Our evaluation shows that the explicit documentation of assumptions in the behavior specification supports both the identification of specification insufficiencies and their treatment. Therefore, this article provides requirements, terminology and an according methodology to facilitate ontology-based behavior specifications in automated driving.
1 March 2023 in at - Automatisierungstechnik
Zusammenfassung Um bereits in der Konzeptphase autonomer Fahrzeuge einen fundierten Eindruck bestehender Risikopotenziale zu erhalten, werden im Zuge von deduktiven und induktiven SOTIF-Analysen mögliche auslösende Umstände für gefährliches Verhalten untersucht. In diesem Zusammenhang wird in der ISO 21448 die Durchführung einer systemtheoretischen Prozessanalyse (STPA) vorgeschlagen. In diesem Beitrag führen wir deutsche Terminologie für SOTIF-Betrachtungen ein und setzen uns im Zuge einer Anwendung kritisch mit der STPA-Theorie auseinander, wobei wir begleitend methodische Ergänzungen anregen.
22 December 2025 in IEEE Access
ISO 21448:2022 specifies normative guidelines to ensure the safety of the intended functionality (SOTIF) of Automated Driving Systems. For systems that allow SAE Level 3 or higher driving automation [1] there is a (partial) absence of human oversight. This requires developers to shift from ensuring controllability by the driver to ensuring that the Automated Driving System exhibits safe behavior in its environment. In the automotive functional safety domain, functional and technical safety concepts are established for the specification of safety measures to mitigate the malfunctioning behavior of E/E systems. However, ISO 21448 does not describe how a comparable safety concept regarding SOTIF can be generated that specifies safety measures for behavior at the vehicle level. Based on the terminology and objectives that are specified in ISO 21448, we elicit requirements for the specification (safe) behavior. Subsequently, we present the conceptualization of a behavioral safety concept that specifies safety measures at the vehicle level. We follow a model-based approach to specify target behavior and document the conducted safety analyses. The semi-formal models provide traceability between functional insufficiencies in the target behavior and the according safety measures. To show the applicability of the proposed meta-model, we create an example model instance of a behavioral safety concept. The example model is based on a domain-specific SysML profile in a selected scenario. Finally, we verify the presented approach against ISO 21448 objectives.