2 December 2022 in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
The presence of a pore fluid is recognized to significantly increase the mobility of saturated over dry granular flows. However, the mechanisms through which pore fluid increases mobility may not be captured in experimental flows of small volume typical of laboratory conditions. Here we present the results of dry and initially fluid saturated or “wet” experimental flows of near‐monodisperse coarse‐grained ceramic particles in a large laboratory flume for five source volumes of 0.2–1.0 m3. Measurements include flow height, velocity profile, pore pressure, and evolving solid volume fraction, as well as the final deposit shape. The dry experiments constrain the frictional properties of the common granular material and comparison with wet flows permits an independent evaluation of the interstitial fluid effects. These results demonstrate that flow dilation and strong variation in the velocity profile are directly linked to a greatly increased mobility for wet granular flows compared to dry, and a significant influence of scale as controlled by source volume on flow behavior. Excess pore pressure need not be present for these effects to occur.
6 February 2024 in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
Field observations of debris flows often show that a deep dry granular front is followed by a progressively thinner and increasingly watery tail. These features have been captured in recent laboratory flume experiments (Taylor-Noonan et al., J. Geophys. Res.: Earth Surf., vol. 127, 2022, e2022JF006622). In these experiments different initial release volumes were used to investigate the dynamics of an undersaturated monodisperse grain–water mixture as it flowed downslope onto a horizontal run-out pad. Corresponding dry granular flows, with the same particle release volumes, were also studied to show the effect of the interstitial fluid. The inclusion of water makes debris flows much more mobile than equivalent volumes of dry grains. In the wet flows, the formation of a dry front is crucially dependent on the heterogeneous vertical structure of the flow and the velocity shear. These effects are included in the depth-averaged theory of Meng et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 943, 2022, A19), which is used in this paper to quantitatively simulate both the wet and dry experimental flows using a high-resolution shock-capturing scheme. The results show that velocity shear causes dry grains (located near the free surface) to migrate forwards to create a dry front. The front is more resistant to motion than the more watery material behind, which reduces the overall computed run-out distance compared with debris-flow models that assume plug flow and develop only small dry snouts. Velocity shear also implies that there is a net transport of water to the back of the flow. This creates a thin oversaturated tail that is unstable to roll waves in agreement with experimental observations.
1 March 2021 in Physics of Fluids
The granular column collapse experiment is an important benchmark case for the physical and numerical study of transitional mass flows. Unlike columns of dry granular materials, the presence of a relatively incompressible fluid, such as water, in the voids of saturated columns complicates the shear behavior of the column by becoming a function of the coupled shear and volumetric behavior of the grain–fluid system. Dilative or contractive behavior at the pore level will cause a decrease or increase, respectively, in the pore fluid pressure. These changes in effective stress, in turn, will define stability or instability and length of runout. Here we use the new opportunity provided by transparent soil to observe air entry within saturated columns to explore the hypothesis that the entry pressure provides the maximum contribution of capillary pressure at incipient failure, thereby providing a quantitative control on the stability of dilative granular columns. Furthermore, the mobility of densely packed saturated columns subject to collapse was significantly influenced by air entry. An analytical model, based on this assumption of limiting capillary pressure, is able to describe the stability of the experimental columns as well as the larger dataset from the literature, reframing the previous empirical stability threshold using limit equilibrium and soil material parameters. Our results demonstrate the importance of stress-dilatancy and air-entry phenomena on the rapid shear behavior of saturated granular materials.
16 October 2021 in Granular Matter
1 January 2025 in Canadian Geotechnical Journal
Laboratory landslide flume studies have revealed that saturated granular flows experience greater mobility than their dry counterparts, being notably faster, farther reaching, and experiencing enhanced spreading. The ability to reliably measure basal pore water pressures is critical for developing, evaluating, and validating constitutive relationships linking the effects of pore pressure to the mechanisms causing increased mobility. Unfortunately, experience has shown that two identical sensors installed in the base of a landslide flume can yield wildly different responses to the same multi-phase landslide. In this paper we explore the hypothesis that the elevation of pore water pressure sensor filter elements can influence sensor readings. A unique experimental strategy of simplifying the flow into a single fluid phase is used to validate sensor readings, prior to application in multi-phase flows. Dam-break releases of 600 kg of water at the top of the inclined flume slope are used as a parametric study to provide evidence to support the hypothesis that sensor roughness significantly impacts the pore pressure recorded in high velocity flows. These results are then contrasted to observations of releases of multi-phase flows to derive best practices for the reliable measurement of pore pressure in landslide flume tests.
2 June 2022 in ESS Open Archive
The presence of a pore fluid is recognized to significantly increase the mobility of saturated over dry granular flows. However, experimental studies in which both the bulk-scale (runout) and grain-scale behaviour of identical granular material in a dry and saturated initial state are directly compared are rare. Further, the mechanisms through which pore fluid increases mobility may not be captured in experimental flows of small volume typical of laboratory conditions. Here we present the results of dry and initially fluid saturated or ‘wet’ experimental flows in a large laboratory flume for five source volumes of 0.2 to cubic metre. Our results demonstrate that the striking differences in the nature of interactions at the particle scale between wet and dry flows can be directly linked to macro-scale behaviour: in particular, a greatly increased mobility for wet granular flows compared to dry, and a significant influence of scale as controlled by source volume. This dataset provides valuable test scenarios to explore the fundamental mechanisms through which the presence of a pore fluid increases flow mobility by first constraining the frictional properties of the material (dry experiments), permitting an independent evaluation of the implementation of interstitial fluid effects in numerical runout models (wet experiments).