25 May 2022 in Earth and Planetary Science Letters
30 March 2024 in Geophysical Journal International
The seismic b-value in Gutenberg–Richter law is an important parameter in earthquake science research and earthquake risk assessment. People have tried to use b-values for short-term earthquake forecasts, and this requires the premise of estimating reliable b-values for real-time seismic catalogs. However, estimating b-values for real-time catalogs, which are usually of poor qualities, is usually faced with many difficulties and problems. In this study, through a series of numerical tests, we investigate the performance of three methods, including the commonly used maximum likelihood estimation method and two relatively new b-value estimation methods, namely the b-positive and K − M slope methods, on calculating b-values for real-time seismic catalogs. We also apply these three methods to both observed seismic catalogs (the seismic sequence in the Costa Marchigiana, Italy, and a high-resolution early aftershock sequence of the 2023 two Mw ∼7.8 earthquakes in Türkiye) and synthetic real-time seismic catalogs. The results in this study show that it seems difficult to obtain accurate b-values for real-time earthquake catalogs by each of these three methods, but the combination of these methods may give a better judgment—if all three methods suggest that the change in b-value is significant, the probability of making a correct decision is very high. Facing the uncertainty of b-value estimation that always exists, we advocate exploring the effectiveness of standard b-value estimation strategies in practical applications.
29 March 2023 in Seismological Research Letters
The b‐value of the Gutenberg–Richter law describes the relationship of size and frequency distribution of earthquakes. Its variations may be related to stress state, hence has been used for short‐term earthquake forecasting. However, estimation of b‐value faces many uncertainties, making it difficult to interpret b‐value changes as tectonic signals or statistical artifacts. Some recent studies have suggested that the b‐values of some seismic catalogs are proportional to the K−M slope (KMS) obtained from the visibility graph analysis. If confirmed, the KMS may provide additional constraints to the b‐value and its variations. In this study, we used synthetic seismic catalogs that obey various probability distributions to demonstrate that the proportional relationship between KMS and b‐value is universal and stable, and that the KMS/b ratio is dependent on the catalog size. We found that the KMS estimation can perform better than the commonly used b‐value estimation methods, especially when the catalogs are incomplete or have variations in the magnitude–frequency relations. We proposed an improved KMS method to ensure that the KMS value provides pure magnitude information and is not affected by the occurrence time or orders of the events. We used the KMS to estimate the spatiotemporal variations of b‐value in the northeastern Tibetan plateau; the results are consistent with those derived from traditional b‐value estimation methods. We suggest that the KMS can be used as a verification of or a supplement to the b‐value.
20 February 2025 in AGU Advances
The stress field perturbation caused by magmatic intrusions within volcanic systems induces strain in the surrounding region. This effect results in the opening and closing of microcracks in the vicinity of the intrusion, which can affect regional seismic velocities. In late November 2023, we deployed a distributed acoustic sensing interrogator to convert an existing 100‐km telecommunication fiber‐optic cable along the coast of Iceland's Reykjanes peninsula into a dense seismic array, which has run continuously. Measuring changes in surface wave moveout with ambient noise cross‐correlation, we observe up to 2% changes in Rayleigh wave phase velocity following eruptions in the peninsula's 2023–2024 sequence that are likely associated with magmatic intrusions into the eruption‐feeding dike. We apply a Bayesian inversion to compute the posterior distribution of potential dike opening models for each eruption by considering measurements for varying channel pairs and frequency bands, and assuming this velocity change is tied to volumetric strain associated with dike‐opening. Our results are in agreement with those based on geodetic measurement and provide independent constraints on the depth of the dike, demonstrating the viability of this novel inversion and new volcano monitoring directions through fiber sensing.
17 October 2025 in Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America
The magnitude–frequency distribution (MFD), which quantifies the relative frequency of large versus small earthquakes, is commonly used in seismic hazard assessment studies and is thought to characterize earthquake dynamics. The classic Gutenberg–Richter (GR) model posits that earthquake frequency decays exponentially with magnitude. The tapered Gutenberg–Richter (TGR) model is a variant that assumes a further reduced frequency of larger earthquakes. Distinguishing which of these two distributions better fits observations is important not only for a better understanding of earthquake physics but also for robust forecasting of earthquake magnitudes. Therefore, we evaluate methods used to differentiate these two distributions and their statistical significance given a set of observations. We find the likelihood-ratio test to be the most effective approach. It rarely misclassifies a GR distribution as a TGR distribution, whereas a TGR distribution can be misclassified as GR when the tail of the MFD is insufficiently sampled. We demonstrate that the probability of correctly identifying a TGR model exceeds 90% when the corner magnitude is one unit smaller than the maximum magnitude predicted by the GR distribution. Furthermore, we introduce an objective framework aimed at detecting potential temporal shifts between the two distributions. We apply this framework to global seismicity and two observational cases of induced seismicity. The MFD of global seismicity shows transitions between GR and TGR distributions over time, which might be explained by either inherent temporal variation in behavior or by the random sampling of a bilinear GR model with a larger b value for M > 7.6. Regarding the induced seismicity cases, we demonstrate significant and persistent TGR distributions in seismicity induced by geothermal well stimulations at Otaniemi, Finland. Furthermore, we find that earthquakes in the Coso geothermal field (California) exhibit TGR behavior during a specific period, likely influenced by the type of magnitude scale used.
22 May 2025 in Seismological Research Letters
Ambient noise interferometry is widely used to detect subsurface changes. These measurements primarily rely on Rayleigh waves or coda waves, with the latter typically interpreted as Rayleigh waves through the application of the diffusion approximation based on the selected lapse window. Converting or inverting the detected changes in Rayleigh- or coda-wave velocity into stress changes requires an understanding of how body-wave velocity responds to stress changes—a relationship defined by stress sensitivity. In this study, we extract stress sensitivity from laboratory experiments and demonstrate that it decreases dramatically with confining pressure and, consequently, with depth. We further collect field measurements to support this relationship. On this basis, we conduct synthetic tests to show that temporal changes in low-frequency (0.05–1 Hz) Rayleigh-wave velocity related to static stress changes may predominantly reflect conditions within the uppermost 1 km of the crust, as shallow S-wave velocities are much more sensitive to stress perturbations than deeper ones. We review previous seismological observations and identify inconsistencies in some interpretations when the depth dependence of stress sensitivity is overlooked, suggesting that the depth corresponding to the detected velocity change may be much shallower than claimed in some previous studies. Our results provide a theoretical foundation by establishing the quantitative relationship between body-wave velocity changes and stress changes, which can improve the interpretation of temporal variations in wavespeeds and emphasize the need for careful analysis given the complexities of real-Earth observations.