Introduction: Muscle weakness can lead to reduced physical function and quality of life. Computed tomography (CT) can be used to assess muscle health through measures of muscle cross-sectional area and density loss associated with fat infiltration. However, there are limited opportunities to measure muscle density in clinically acquired CT scans because a density calibration phantom, allowing for the conversion of CT Hounsfield units into density, is typically not included within the field-of-view. For bone density analysis, internal density calibration methods use regions of interest within the scan field-of-view to derive the relationship between Hounsfield units and bone density, but these methods have yet to be adapted for muscle density analysis. The objective of this study was to design and validate a CT internal calibration method for muscle density analysis. Methodology: We CT scanned 10 bovine muscle samples using two scan protocols and five scan positions within the scanner bore. The scans were calibrated using internal calibration and a reference phantom. We tested combinations of internal calibration regions of interest (e.g., air, blood, bone, muscle, adipose). Results: We found that the internal calibration method using two regions of interest, air and adipose or blood, yielded accurate muscle density values (< 1% error) when compared with the reference phantom. The muscle density values derived from the internal and reference phantom calibration methods were highly correlated (R2 > 0.99). The coefficient of variation for muscle density across two scan protocols and five scan positions was significantly lower for internal calibration (mean = 0.33%) than for Hounsfield units (mean = 6.52%). There was no difference between coefficient of variation for the internal calibration and reference phantom methods. Conclusions: We have developed an internal calibration method to produce accurate and reliable muscle density measures from opportunistic computed tomography images without the need for calibration phantoms.
Osteoarthritis affects joints of the hand and is radiographically characterized by joint space narrowing and changes in volumetric bone mineral density (vBMD). High-resolution peripheral computed tomography (HR-pQCT) allows for three-dimensional analysis of joint space width (JSW) changes but has yet to be applied to hand OA (HOA). The purpose of this study was to assess the utility of HR-pQCT in quantifying JSW and vBMD changes in HOA. The 2nd and 3rd distal interphalangeal (DIP2, DIP3) and trapeziometacarpal (TMC) joints of 20 women (10 controls, 10 HOA) were scanned using HR-pQCT. The Diseases of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) questionnaire and the Jebsen Hand Function Test (JHFT) were obtained. Radiographs were scored using the Eaton-Littler classification. We assessed between-group differences in HR-pQCT outcomes, and relationships between HR-pQCT outcomes and patient and radiographic characteristics. JSW maximum (JSW.Max) was higher in OA patients in the DIP2 (OA median [interquartile rage]: 2.07 mm [1.90–2.18], controls: 1.88 mm [1.84–1.89]) and DIP3 joints (OA: 2.01 mm [1.89–2.24], controls: 1.86 mm [1.82–1.95]). DIP3 JS volume was higher in OA (30.36 mm3, 19.35–34.57 mm3, controls: 17.05 mm3, 15.53–18.52 mm3). DASH scores were positively associated with DIP2 JSW asymmetry (JSW.AS), and JHFT times were positively associated with DIP3 JSW.Max, JSW.AS, and proximal DIP2 vBMD. Worsening radiographic TMC OA was associated with first metacarpal vBMD, JSW minimum, JSW.Max, and JSW.AS. These preliminary findings suggest that HR-pQCT may be useful in investigating JS changes in HOA and warrants further investigation.
Bone alterations and degenerative joint structural changes are frequently observed in knee osteoarthritis (OA). Objective measures of subchondral bone plate thickness (SBP.Th), apparent BMD, and joint space width (JSW) have begun to be used to better assess and understand disease progression. Weight-bearing CT (WBCT) allows 3D assessment of multiple bone and joint parameters; however, there is a paucity of literature investigating factors that might affect our ability to track changes over time. The purpose of this study was to investigate the repeatability of BMD, JSW, and SBP.Th measures obtained from WBCT images. Same-day, scan–rescan, knee WBCT images were acquired from 37 healthy adults (20 female, mean age: 24.6 yr). We quantified trabecular bone BMD at the proximal tibia and implemented joint space and cortical bone mapping to measure tibiofemoral JSW and SBP.Th, respectively. Test–retest repeatability was evaluated using coefficients of variation (CVRMS%) and least significant change (LSC). Mean trabecular BMD exhibited CVRMS% ranging from 1.87% to 2.85% and LSCs between 13.53 and 17.39 mgHA/cm3. For JSW, CVRMS% and LSC were less than 1% and 0.2 mm, respectively. SBP.Th measures had higher CVRMS% (9.75%-11.29%) but similar LSC values (0.09-0.26 mm) in comparison to JSW values. The high repeatability of subchondral bone and joint parameters underscore the potential of WBCT for quantifying and monitoring bone and joint changes in knee OA progression and management. However, standardization of acquisition and analysis methods will likely be required to ensure reliable evaluation over multiple time points.
The Open and Reproducible Musculoskeletal Imaging Research (ORMIR) community is a scientific community dedicated to promoting openness and reproducibility in musculoskeletal imaging, image processing, and computational modelling. In this perspective paper, we outline the motivations for conducting transparent research and provide practical guidelines to implement it. We start with defining open and reproducible research and describing the benefits and challenges of working transparently. Next, we redefine the outputs of a computational research study as—ideally—a combination of data, code, and a publication, recommend a folder and file structure that reflects these three study outcomes, and describe how to maintain and update such a structure during the study and at study publication. Finally, we emphasize that working in an open and reproducible manner is a learning process and the best way to acquire the necessary competencies is simply to start. Lay summary: The ORMIR community promotes openness and reproducibility in musculoskeletal imaging research. In this perspective paper, we explain why transparency matters and recommend how to conduct a computational study in an open and reproducible manner focusing on its three outputs: data, code, and publication. Finally, we highlight that the best way to learn these practices is simply to start.