Fishing activity is closely monitored to an increasing degree, but its effects on biodiversity have not received such attention. Using iconic and well-studied fish species such as tunas, billfishes, and sharks, we calculate a continuous Red List Index of yearly changes in extinction risk over 70 years to track progress toward global sustainability and biodiversity targets. We show that this well-established biodiversity indicator is highly sensitive and responsive to fishing mortality. After ~58 years of increasing risk of extinction, effective fisheries management has shifted the biodiversity loss curve for tunas and billfishes, whereas the curve continues to worsen for sharks, which are highly undermanaged. While populations of highly valuable commercial species are being rebuilt, the next management challenge is to halt and reverse the harm afflicted by these same fisheries to broad oceanic biodiversity.
Fisheries management relies on catch level projections developed from stock assessment models. Assumptions about future recruitment are highly influential when forecasting the catch levels that lead fisheries towards management objectives. Yet, there are not precise guidelines for configuring forward projections, and scientists around the world use different methods and assumptions. In this article, we review various assumptions made in fishery stock assessments to set up catch level projections. In addition, we identify an approach that matches recent stock dynamics with the projection period while maintaining the link between spawners and recruits. We recommend adjusting the equilibrium stock–recruitment relationship using the average recruitment deviations estimated during the last years of the assessment period. First applied to Indian Ocean Yellowfin Tuna in 2024, this approach was designed to handle recruitment trends and possible model misspecification. We consider this approach best suited for developing catch level projections from integrated stock assessments and conducting simulations in management strategy evaluation.