Athletes face many transitional periods in their sporting careers. One transitional experience within the sport of ice hockey is within-organization transitions (i.e., being ‘called up’ or being ‘sent down’), which is where an individual is promoted and or demoted from a team. While these types of transitions are common, little is known about the individual experiences of the athletes who undergo such transitions. To help address this void, the present study utilized a phenomenological lens to explore and interpret athletes’ lived experiences with such transitions. Semi- structured interviews with six professional ice-hockey players within North American leagues, including but not limited to the NHL, AHL, ECHL, SPHL, and FHL, were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data were analyzed using an interpretive phenomenological analysis approach. Results were presented in two clusters: (a) unique approaches to coping during the transition and (b) navigating the politics, the system, and the environment. Overall, it was determined that the experiences of those who have undergone such transitions are complex and nuanced and were perceived to lead toward positive, negative, or neutral outcomes from a social, emotional, financial, and psychological perspective. Given the nature of some of the more tumultuous experiences that athletes shared, it is clear that more research is needed to better understand how to support athletes during these types of transitions, with the hopes of fostering healthier, safer, and more positive sport experiences for athletes. The current findings can serve to inform coach education and can help act as a tool for preparing athletes pursuing professional ice hockey.