This review and reflection paper presents the importance of organic amendments (OA) from agro-industrial waste, such as compost, biochar, or hydrochar, due to their increasing use in the horticulture field, as an organic nutrient source and the circular economy application. However, its production is not controlled by the environmental authorities in countries of Latin America, such as Colombia, and there is no obligation to make a quality control analysis of these materials once they are ready to be released onto the market. As the main source of these materials is urban solid waste, the first part of the paper introduces how its management is, placing emphasis on the opportunity to strengthen its production and use as soil amendments in the agricultural sector. The second part of the document shows briefly how the production of the most common OA, such as compost, biochar, or hydrochar is, and some physicochemical analysis of them, from different sources. This provides evidence of the variability of these materials even more when they are commercialized as the same thing. In the final section, some recommendations for the horticulture sector are described, especially in the use of OA, as well as a sustainable and portable small-scale reactor to produce some OA in local communities, using agricultural waste. An alternative that combines environmental, economic, and sustainability benefits for the rural population. Methodologically, there were different sources of information due to the application's increasing novelty in Latin America. First, institutional/public information-related regulation of OAs is the most confident source on this topic. Secondly, scientific papers and chemical analyses of different commercial OAs were checked to demonstrate the threats of their use in horticulture. In this way, the document gives a broad perspective on the use of this kind of material to the farmers, to make the best production decisions.