The reliability of active prostheses remains a significant challenge due to the inherent vulnerabilities of non-invasive human-machine interfaces (HMIs), such as electromyography (EMG), which are highly susceptible to noise, perspiration, muscle fatigue, electrode shift, and other factors. To overcome these limitations, this work introduces capacitive touch sensing as a novel HMI for upper-limb prostheses that shifts the sensing paradigm from measuring muscle bio-potentials to detecting residual-limb movement-induced capacitance variations. The change in capacitance resulting from limb-electrode contact dynamics within the prosthetic socket yields stable, noise-resistant signals for prosthetic control. Unlike conventional muscle-machine interfaces, this method incorporates sensors within the socket wall, eliminating the need for direct skin-electrode adhesion and its associated discomfort. The HMI system was developed and validated with 12 participants, including 2 individuals with upper-limb impairments, and its efficiency was evaluated against EMG. Experimental results indicate consistent signal quality for capacitive sensing under rigorous conditions. While EMG performance degraded considerably under sweat and fatigue, the capacitive interface maintained high accuracy (> 92%) across all scenarios. A proposed thresholding technique eliminates false actuations caused by limb micromovements and artifacts with over 97% accuracy, obviating the need for supplementary inertial sensors. Additionally, the capacitive interface achieved 90% accuracy, significantly outperforming EMG (63%) in a three-gesture classification task. User feedback indicated enhanced comfort, reduced fatigue, and ease of learning, emphasizing the system’s practical feasibility. Overall, this work validates capacitive sensing as a reliable and robust modality, and thus a promising candidate for the primary HMI in upper-limb prosthetic control.