Solar energy is the fastest-growing renewable electricity source globally. Under the guise of the green transition, solar energy is portrayed by energy optimists as sustainable despite its negative environmental and social externalities. The justice and equity dynamics of solar energy adoption have not been adequately explored in the Global South, where there are fewer incentives to transition away from carbon-based energy. South Africa poses a unique exception where, under a national energy crisis, load shedding (i.e. rolling electricity outages) has led to an exponential increase in household solar adoption. In order to quantify energy justice dynamics, we manually mapped solar installations for a representative sample of 300 urban census tracts across South Africa. We found that while solar adoption increased at a rate of 140% per year between 2016 and 2023, it was unevenly distributed over socio-economic geographies, particularly when comparing white and previously disadvantaged population groups (Black African, Colored, and Indian). Household solar adoption was close to zero in census tracts with income levels just above or below the poverty line, whereas high-income tracts installed nearly 2 panels per household, on average. Similarly, solar adoption is 73 times higher in majority white census tracts compared to those with majority previously disadvantaged racial groups (average of 3.5 m2 vs 0.048 m2 panel area per person). Using satellites that measure nighttime light radiance, we found that solar panel adoption is associated with less severe nighttime light declines, suggesting solar increases household resilience to load shedding. Census tracts with majority Black African residents show declines in nighttime light that are twice as large as those in majority White tracts, thereby mirroring the solar adoption pattern. Our findings illustrate the extremes of energy injustice in the Global South where existing social asymmetries are perpetuated and amplified in the green energy transition.
20 February 2025 in Environmental Research: Energy
Energy poverty is a multifaceted and urgent issue in the Global South, especially in South Africa, where, despite an electrification rate exceeding 90%, a substantial 40% of the population still experiences energy poverty. This paper presents a systematic review of literature on energy poverty in South Africa, covering the period from 1994 to 2023. The review identifies eleven key themes that offer a multi-dimensional perspective on such energy poverty. It offers insights into addressing critical issues for advancing an equitable and just energy system. Understanding the extent and nature of energy poverty could facilitate a deeper understanding of (in)justices entrenched in South Africa’s socio-technical energy system, for policymakers, practitioners and experts alike. Energy justice is employed as an analytical framework to examine the implications of energy poverty through the lenses of restorative, distributive, procedural, and recognitional justice. The analysis seeks to contribute to South Africa’s just transition (JT) Framework, which currently addresses energy poverty primarily as a matter of restorative justice. South Africa’s just energy transition cannot be achieved in an inclusive and transformative manner without accounting for multifaceted dynamics at the household level; here, energy poverty serves to bring about a more intersectional focus on the justice dimensions inherent in energy transitions. The findings underscore the need to address energy poverty at the household level, where it intersects with broader socio-technical dynamics. Such a multi-dimensional perspective on energy poverty in South Africa could help to inform targeted policies and initiatives to meet the specific needs of energy-poor households, while broader socio-technical changes are accelerated as part of the energy transition, thus more strongly meeting the goals spelled out in the JT Framework.
26 September 2024 in South African Journal of Science
Inter- and transdisciplinary curricula can potentially develop an integrated understanding of an increasingly interconnected, complex world and develop students’ agency, empathy, creativity and critical thinking skills. Within the South African qualification landscape, the Postgraduate Diploma (PGDip) is identified as a multi- or interdisciplinary qualification that allows working professionals ‘to undertake advanced reflection and development by means of a systematic survey of current thinking, practice and research methods in an area of specialisation’. In this paper, four academics reflexively share their experiences of (re)developing and piloting transdisciplinary curricula for the PGDip in Sustainable Development (at Stellenbosch University) and the PGDip in Sustainability Learning (at Rhodes University). Reflections centre around the rationale, context and emergence of the two programmes, their structure and intended learning outcomes, and principles guiding the overall curriculum design. We highlight the appropriateness of transdisciplinary approaches to curricula focused on the sustainability field, and it distils three broad features of the two PGDip programmes that seem important – even necessary – for developing students’ competencies as sustainability practitioners. These are ontological groundedness, epistemological openness and ethical attentiveness.
Low-income households in South Africa’s rapidly urbanising cities often face significant challenges in accessing grid electricity. These challenges are illustrative of the limitations of conventional municipality-led grid expansion, and necessitate the exploration of alternative energy solutions that could reshape energy provision in these contexts. To better understand how such alternative solutions are envisioned and realised, this paper examines an imaginary-in-the-making around off-grid electrification in informal settlements through decentralised renewable energy infrastructures. Drawing on three case studies in the City of Cape Town (CCT), it explores the social and political dynamics of this emerging off-grid electricity imaginary, and explores technical solutions for solar home systems, mini-grids, and solar-powered public lighting. At the heart of these dynamics lies the transformative shift towards the formal recognition of this imaginary in the CCT’s 2050 Energy Strategy, published in 2023. Employing dramaturgical analysis, with the Triple-Re Framework (TRF), this paper aims to understand how alternative energy imaginaries can gain traction in African cities. We argue that the dynamics around the off-grid electricity imaginary can be understood as a ‘dramaturgy of incrementalism’ a dramaturgy that creates a new political reality for informal settlements and opens up new forms of urban citizenship. The case studies demonstrate how (i) off-grid electricity imaginaries help re-imagine how renewable energy can improve electricity access in African cities while promoting equity and inclusivity, and (ii) how the dynamics around the imaginary open up new opportunities for political participation, contestation, and urban citizenship.
South Africa’s worsening inequality and unemployment and high greenhouse gas emissions require climate-resilient strategies that empower local governments. Responding to the country’s highly contested energy transition and bringing together decarbonization and development priorities are critical for all spheres of government. The energy transition presents a confluence of challenges and opportunities for climate action that are exacerbated in urban settings. The needs of vulnerable households must deliberately be centred for energy transition responses that support just and inclusive climate action. Targeting energy poverty sheds light on household energy behaviour that can promote inclusive shifts to cleaner, affordable, and safe energy sources and inform appropriate urban climate action strategies by local governments. Drawing from experience with energy poverty alleviation in the City of Cape Town (CCT), we argue that a context-sensitive understanding of energy poverty is required to support urban climate resilience and inclusive development. CCT has made progress with centring energy poverty in its climate resilience and urban development strategies, signified in the establishment of the Energy Poverty Alleviation team in 2017, plus the inclusion of energy poverty as a pillar in the 2050 Energy Strategy. We reflect on these efforts to mainstream energy poverty alleviation within CCT and elaborate on interventions and partnerships that demonstrate this strategic commitment. We further emphasize five priorities for research and innovation for climate action from the vantage point that energy poverty alleviation is a critical dimension of local governments’ climate action strategies and South Africa’s broader just energy transition.