Finite element (FE) model updating of bridges is based on the measured modal parameters and less frequently on the measured structural response under a known load. Until recently, the FE model updating did not consider strain measurements from sensors installed for weighing vehicles with bridge weigh-in-motion (B-WIM) systems. A 50-year-old multi-span concrete highway viaduct, renovated between 2017 and 2019, was equipped with continuous monitoring system with over 200 sensors, and a B-WIM system. In the most heavily instrumented span, the maximum measured longitudinal strains induced by the full-speed calibration vehicle passages were compared with the modelled strains. Based on the sensitivity study results, three variables that affected its overall stiffness were updated: Young’s modulus adjustment factor of all structural elements, and two anchorage reduction factors that considered the interaction between the superstructure and non-structural elements. The analysis confirmed the importance of the initial manual FE model updating to correctly reflect the non-structural elements during the automatic nonlinear optimisation. It also demonstrated a successful use of pseudo-static B-WIM loading data during the model updating process and the potential to extend the proposed approach to using random B-WIM-weighed vehicles for FE model updating and long-term monitoring of structural parameters and load-dependent phenomena.
In developing a digital twin of a real structure, finite element model updating (FEMU) is essential for refining the model’s response based on measured data, enabling the detection of structural damage or hidden reserves over time. This case study focused on a 40-year-old multi-span concrete roadway bridge, equipped with permanent bridge weigh-in-motion (B-WIM) and structural health monitoring (SHM) systems. Bridge responses from two calibration vehicles were used to derive strain influence lines (ILs) from mid-span B-WIM strain transducers mounted on the main girders. The error-domain model falsification (EDMF) methodology was applied to perform strain IL-based FEMU and the more conventional frequency-based, MAC-based, and combined frequency and MAC-based FEMU. Boundary conditions and three Young’s modulus adjustment factors, representing different groups of structural elements, were updated. The strain IL-based updated FE model, with averages of 35% and 50% stiffness increases for the two main girders, showed strong agreement with independently measured mid-span vertical displacements. Maximum values deviated not more than 5%. In contrast, the frequency and MAC-based updated FE model underestimated displacements by 25–30%. These findings highlight the potential of using B-WIM for FEMU and SHM on such types of bridges, particularly when the response under traffic load is of interest.
Most finite element model updating (FEMU) studies on bridges are acceleration-based due to their lower cost and ease of use compared to strain- or displacement-based methods, which entail costly experiments and traffic disruptions. This leads to a scarcity of comprehensive studies incorporating strain measurements. This study employed the strain- and acceleration-based FEMU analyses performed on a more than 50-year-old multi-span concrete highway viaduct. Mid-span strains under heavy vehicles were considered for the strain-based FEMU, and frequencies and mode shapes for the acceleration-based FEMU. The analyses were performed separately for up to three variables, representing Young’s modulus adjustment factors for different groups of structural elements. FEMU studies considered residual minimisation and the error-domain model falsification (EDMF) methodology. The residual minimisation utilised four different single-objective optimisations focusing on strains, frequencies, and mode shapes. Strain- and frequency-based FEMU analyses resulted in an approximately 20% increase in the overall superstructure’s design stiffness. This study shows the benefits of the intuitive EDMF over residual minimisation for FEMU, where information gained from the strain data, in addition to the acceleration data, manifests more sensible updated variables. EDMF finally resulted in a 25–50% overestimated design stiffness of internal main girders.
Bridges rarely behave precisely according to design assumptions. In most cases, they have some hidden reserves and behave preferable under traffic loads. To take these benefits into consideration numerical models can be calibrated based on measured structural response. The case study presented herein shows the calibration process for a railway truss bridge in Austria and the comparison of calibration results obtained by two individual teams. Each team did an individual and independent calibration based on different finite element models based on measured train passages. Both calibrations improved the precision of the calculated model response compared to the initial model, but also showed that the calibration parameters must be chosen with care to ensure plausibility of the results.