Immigrant women’s perceptions and needs are not well-represented in the health literature. In order to address the gap, this study explores personal and system-level barriers to accessing healthcare services among immigrant women, and their coping mechanisms to overcome these barriers. Using eight databases, a total of 147 studies were retrieved. Of these studies, 11 qualitative studies were selected and synthesized. A theory-generating qualitative meta-synthesis (QMS) approach was used to analyze and synthesize raw qualitative data. The QMS results indicate that immigrant women face personal-level barriers (lack of transportation, insurance, trust, inadequate financial capacity, and insufficient health information, gender, legal status, language proficiency) and system-level barriers (discrimination, miscommunication, complexity, lack of cultural competence) in accessing healthcare services. Immigrant women mainly rely on family and community support, and cultural solutions as coping strategies to overcome these barriers. Implications include policymakers and healthcare providers should adopt culturally relevant and inclusive approaches, disseminate multi-lingual health information, and work in collaboration with immigrant women and their community support groups to tackle the challenges. Future research may focus on subgroups of immigrant women to develop more culturally competent and practical collaborative solutions, and examine healthcare providers’ perspectives, as well as immigrant women’s perspectives.
Background: Immigrants with disabilities (IWDs) are disproportionately affected by a lack of access to healthcare services and face unique challenges compared to the general population. This qualitative meta-synthesis examines the barriers, facilitators, and lived experiences of IWDs accessing healthcare in the U.S. and Canada. Methods: A theory-generating qualitative meta-synthesis approach was used to analyze and synthesize raw qualitative data. Using eight databases, 752 studies were retrieved, and 10 were selected and synthesized after a three-stage review. The final articles were assessed using the Critical Appraisal Skills Program (CASP) checklist, and a PRISMA flow chart was used to report on the selection process. Results: The analysis identified structural barriers, including the bureaucracy and complexity of the system, healthcare costs, transportation, communication, long wait times, and a lack of integrated services. Cultural barriers included denial and trust, stigma and discrimination, awareness and language gaps, and lack of social support. Facilitators of access included support from immediate family members, community health centers, and social workers. Conclusions: The findings highlight the need for policy reforms to reduce bureaucratic hurdles, improve communication within healthcare systems, and enhance cultural competence among healthcare providers. Addressing these issues through integrated service models and targeted support can significantly improve the quality of life as a result of improved healthcare access for IWDs.
Using data from a cross-sectional online survey among social work students (N = 457) in the US, our study explored differences in mental health status based on sociodemographic characteristics and preventive behaviors during the COVID-19 pandemic. Results showed disparate experiences related to anxiety, depression, self-harming thoughts, stress and hopelessness by age, gender, employment status, marital status, education, number of children, living arrangement, and mask-wearing and social distancing preventive behaviors. Findings provide implications to mitigate both the current and prolonged impact of the pandemic among social work students who will be playing crucial roles in the provision and delivery of health and human services.
16 August 2022 in Applied Research in Quality of Life
This study examined the approaches of the Community Wellbeing Initiative (CWI), a gender-based violence (GBV) prevention program in Ethiopian refugee settings, through the perspectives of social workers. Using the decolonization framework, the study tried to bring the voices of global south social workers into the international discourse. In-depth interviews were conducted with 8 social workers, and transcripts of their interviews were analyzed thematically using Nvivo12 software. Three major themes emerged: “conflicting approaches with the local sociocultural context”, “foreign-based and centralized approaches”, and “aid as an instrument of modern-day imperialism”. The findings showed that the foreign-developed approaches of the CWI conflict with the local context and lack input from local expertise and knowledge. The approaches are highly centralized and limit social workers’ creativity in implementing the program. These findings demonstrated the need for involving local experts in designing GBV intervention programs, following a dialogical bottom-up approach and decolonizing partnerships that use aid as an imperialistic tool for social work services. Future research should further examine cases where local culture plays an oppressive role and find the balance between positive local contexts and global social work values and help expand the decolonization discourse in a direction that ensures relevance to local communities.
Lack of trust is a critical issue in healthcare that contributes to the growing disparities in access and utilization of health among minoritized and disadvantaged populations in the U.S. This study explored how lack of trust affects Ethiopian immigrant women’s (EIW) primary healthcare (PHC) experience and the personal and structural factors exacerbating the problem. A qualitative cross-sectional design was used to collect data through in-depth interviews with EIW (N = 21) living in six states (MO, MD, VA, KS, MI and IN) and Washington DC using a pilot-tested semi-structured interview guide. A mix of purposive and snowball sampling was used to recruit participants who: (1) identify as an Ethiopian immigrant; (2) identify as a female; (3) be 18 years and older; (4) arrived in the U.S. within the last five years; and (5) speak Amharic or English languages. The interviews were recorded, transcribed verbatim, translated and cleaned for errors. An inductive thematic analysis was followed to analyze data using Nvivo12 software. The findings showed that lack of trust is a significant concern among EIW negatively affecting their PHC experience and decisions in seeking care. The thematic analysis revealed five major factors contributing to the erosion of trust in PHC among EIW: (1) reliance on medication in U.S. healthcare system (2) preference for traditional homemade remedies over PHC recommendations and modern medicine (3) faith and its influence on trust and PHC decisions (4) lack of transparency in PHC, and (5) multilevel discrimination in PHC. The analysis suggested that PHC professionals provide understandable and contextualized health information, practice transparency, familiarize themselves with the healthcare system in immigrants’ countries of origin by asking their patients, and prioritize culturally competent care to gain trust. At structural and policy levels, reform is needed to dismantle systemic problems that enable and perpetuate discrimination, diversify the healthcare workforce, revise healthcare training curriculums and procedures to reflect immigrant needs, establish multi-sectoral collaboration between health, education, and immigration sectors to create conducive care environment for immigrants. Further research and conversation around alternative medicine is vital to expand evidence-based and inclusive PHC services for immigrants.