Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) is a new but promising field of information security, with many organizations investing in the development of proper tools and services and the integration of CTI related information. However, as a new field, there is a lack of a conceptual framework with corresponding definitions. This paper discusses CTI complexity factors, proposes a set of definitions of the CTI key concepts and an eight-layer CTI Reference Model as a base for CTI systems design. In addition, the proposed reference model is validated by applying it to three case studies, producing the respective CTI Reference Architectures.
Since its first steps in the cybersecurity field, Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) has gained recognition and increased its importance in the daily operations of cybersecurity teams. However, the many forms of CTI exchanged, the vast amount of CTI products, and the plurality of the sources have raised doubts about the CTI quality. This paper discusses the problem of CTI quality, focusing on the quality factors that better evaluate the products of CTI and how we measure them. Consequently, we propose a methodology for developing and assessing CTI quality metrics and demonstrate the application of this methodology by developing the relevance ( $RE$ ) and weighted completeness ( $WC$ ) metrics for unstructured and structured CTI products, respectively. We created two sets of structured and unstructured CTI data for this demonstration, utilizing them as benchmark datasets for estimating $RE$ and $WC$ .The proposed methodology introduces a systematic approach for developing and assessing quantitative CTI quality metrics for evaluating CTI data and CTI sources.
Cyber Threat intelligence (CTI) systems offer new capabilities in the arsenal of information security experts, who can explore new sources of data that were partially exploited during the past decades. This paper deals with the exploitation of discussion forums as a source of raw data for a cyber threat intelligence process. Specifically, it analyzes the discussion forums’ characteristics and investigates their relationship with CTI. It proposes a semantic schema for the representation of data collected from discussion forums. Then, it applies a systematic methodology to design the reference architecture of the SECDFAN system, which handles the creation of CTI products following a comprehensive approach from the source selection to CTI product sharing and security experts’ collaboration. The final product of this work is the SECDFAN reference architecture. The contribution of this paper is the development of a CTI reference architecture of a system that, by design, handles all CTI-related issues for creating CTI products by analyzing the content of discussion forums.
This paper addresses the critical challenge of evaluating the quality of Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) products, particularly focusing on their relevance and actionability. As organizations increasingly rely on CTI to make cybersecurity decisions, the absence of CTI quality metrics challenges the assessment of intelligence quality. To address this gap, the article introduces two innovative metrics. Relevance () and Actionability () are designed to evaluate CTI products in relation to organizational information needs and defense mechanisms. Using probabilistic algorithms and data structures, these metrics provide a scalable approach for handling large numbers of unstructured CTI products. Experimental findings demonstrate the effectiveness of metrics in filtering and prioritizing CTI products, offering organizations a tool to prioritize their cybersecurity resources. Furthermore, experimental results demonstrate that, using the metrics, organizations can reduce candidate CTI products by several orders of magnitude, understand weaknesses in defining information needs, guide the application of CTI products, assess CTI products’ contribution to defense, and select CTI products from information sharing communities. In addition, the study has identified certain limitations, which open avenues for future research, including the real-time integration of CTI into organizational defense mechanisms. This work significantly contributes to standardizing the quality evaluation of CTI products and enhancing organizations’ cybersecurity posture.
This paper addresses the critical challenge of evaluating the quality of Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) products, particularly focusing on their relevance and actionability. As organizations increasingly rely on CTI to make cybersecurity decisions, the absence of CTI quality metrics challenges the assessment of intelligence quality. To address this gap, the article introduces two innovative metrics. Relevance (Re) and Actionability (Ac), which are designed to evaluate CTI products in relation to organizational information needs and defense mechanisms. Using probabilistic algorithms and data structures, these metrics provide a scalable approach for handling large numbers of unstructured CTI products. Experimental findings demonstrate the effectiveness of metrics in filtering and prioritizing CTI products, offering organizations a tool to prioritize their cybersecurity resources. In addition, the study has identified certain limitations, which opens avenues for future research, including real-time integration of CTI into organizational defense mechanisms. This work significantly contributes to standardizing the quality evaluation of CTI products and enhancing the cybersecurity posture of organizations.
Although the recent trend for the term “cyber-attack” is restricted for incidents causing physical damage, it has been traditionally used to describe a broader range of attempts to make unauthorized use of an asset related to computer information systems, computer networks, or even personal computing devices. As such, a cyber-attack aims to steal, alter a targets’ system/data, or even destroy targets by gaining access into a targeted system. In this respect, a whole new industry has been shaped around the need for protection against cyber-attacks, i.e. the “cyber-security” domain, which primarily deals with the protection of systems (incl. HW/SW & data) connected to the internet against cyber-attacks and should not be necessarily mixed with the domain of Information Technology (IT) Security (see Figure 4.1) that mainly refers to the protection of information. Cyber-security, on the other hand, is the ability to protect or defend the use of cyberspace from cyber-attacks by securing “things”, vulnerable through ICT. Figure 4.1 Information technology security vs cyber-security. https://s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-public-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/9781003337492/51cb024d-c0f0-4f03-818e-5915e5d0ef18/content/fig4_1.tif" xmlns:xlink="https://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"/>