Kadria Abdel Motaal

Dr. Kadria Abdel Motaal

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

2Years (2025-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
AHAbdallah Borham Haroun
Abdallah Borham Haroun
KMKadria Abdel Motaal
Kadria Abdel Motaal
NENour Elsersawy
Nour Elsersawy
YAYassmin Ahmed
Yassmin Ahmed
SMShuaib Mahmoud
Shuaib Mahmoud
AAAnwar Abdelnaser
Anwar Abdelnaser
Background: Disruptions in the mesh of the ecosystem come with implications that severely harm the sustainability and the equilibrium of life. Interactions of humans, animals, and many other organisms, along with the whole ecological complex, have given birth to zoonotic diseases, which can vary in type and burden. Collaborative efforts put into the prioritization of environmental, animal, and human health are envisioned as “One Health”. Understanding vector ecology and the varying mechanistic ways of transmission is crucial for constructing effective One Health surveillance tools and warning systems. Methods: We identified the literature available concerning the subject matter. We utilized scholarly databases to gather research for the last 10 years using predefined keywords. Objectives: This review aims to synthesize current knowledge on the interconnection between climate discrepancies, ecological alarms, and the emergence and spread of zoonotic diseases. We attempted to provide recommendations for future research and policy interventions. Results: Human activities have significantly impacted disease-carrying vectors and wildlife habitats, aiding their proliferation and the spillover of diseases. Global frameworks incorporating One Health principles enhance global preparedness for future health threats. Applying the integrated One Health Surveillance has strengthened early warning systems. Interdisciplinary collaborations and tools like OH-EpiCap, a comprehensive tool that assesses and enhances the capacities of One Health surveillance systems, have significantly contributed to responding to infectious disease outbreaks, as seen in the Netherlands, reducing the risk of tick-borne diseases. Conclusions: Strides have been made with comprehensive processes that identify and prioritize zoonotic diseases of most significant concern and burden, such as OHZDP, approaches like One Health, and other theories considered. A proactive and integrated approach will build resilience against potential outbreaks and ensure a healthier future for our planet and its inhabitants.

KMKadria Abdel Motaal
Kadria Abdel Motaal
SCSungsoo Chun
Sungsoo Chun
Background: The COVID-19 pandemic exposed major structural deficiencies in global health governance, including stark inequities in vaccine access, intervention timing, and mortality outcomes. While economic resources played a role, the influence of governance performance remains insufficiently examined. This study addresses a significant gap by integrating governance metrics with pandemic response data to assess how governance quality, independent of income level, affected national outcomes. Although the Oxford COVID-19 Government Response Tracker (OxCGRT) dataset has been widely used to document policy responses, this study offers a novel contribution by linking these policy interventions with governance performance and evaluating their joint effect on health outcomes and vaccine equity. Methods: This mixed-methods study combines quantitative analysis of global datasets with a qualitative literature review. Quantitative data were mainly obtained from the Oxford COVID-19 Government Response Tracker (OxCGRT), the World Bank’s Worldwide Governance Indicators (WGIs), and World Bank/WHO databases. A governance performance index was constructed using two WGI components: Government Effectiveness and Regulatory Quality. Countries were grouped into high, medium, or low governance categories. Statistical tests included ANOVA, Kaplan Meier survival analysis, and multivariable OLS regression. The qualitative component reviewed 45 academic and institutional sources on governance performance during COVID-19. Results: Countries with high governance performance had earlier public health interventions, lower mortality, and broader vaccine coverage, independent of income level. Kaplan Meier analysis revealed faster school closures in these countries (p < 0.01). Multivariable regression showed governance remained a significant predictor after adjusting for income and health spending. Qualitative findings highlighted recurring weaknesses in legal enforceability, intergovernmental coordination, and global financing mechanisms. Conclusions: Governance performance had a decisive impact on pandemic outcomes. The COVID-19 crisis revealed the need for robust governance systems capable of responding to complex emergencies that extend beyond the health sector into institutional, economic, and social spheres.

KMKadria Abdel Motaal
Kadria Abdel Motaal
WKWafa Ahmed Abu El Kheir-Mataria
Wafa Ahmed Abu El Kheir-Mataria
SCSungsoo Chun
Sungsoo Chun
Background: The COVID-19 pandemic exposed persistent weaknesses in global health governance, particularly in preparedness, equity, and accountability. The WHO Pandemic Agreement, adopted in May 2025, aims to address these systemic gaps through a binding international framework. Objective: To identify key challenges in global pandemic preparedness and health governance reported in the literature (2019–2024) through a systematic scoping review, and to evaluate how these challenges are addressed in the provisions of the WHO Pandemic Agreement via qualitative document analysis. Methods: Using Joanna Briggs Institute methodology and PRISMA-ScR guidelines, we systematically identified and thematically analyzed 52 peer-reviewed studies published between 2020 and 2024. The thematic results informed a qualitative document analysis of the WHO Pandemic Agreement text to assess the extent to which its provisions address the identified challenges. Results: Persistent gaps in governance (limited enforceability, fragmented coordination), equity (inequitable access to medical countermeasures), capacity (technology transfer and financing), and accountability were identified. Health systems in low- and middle-income countries continue to face critical resource constraints and lack robust mechanisms to ensure accountability and continuous learning. Document analysis showed the WHO Pandemic Agreement addresses coordination and financing but offers limited advances in enforcement, technology transfer, and independent monitoring. Conclusion: The WHO Pandemic Agreement introduces important institutional and financing measures, but persistent gaps remain in enforcement, technology transfer, and inclusive implementation. Strengthening these domains is crucial to achieving equitable and resilient preparedness. By systematically linking evidence from the pandemic preparedness literature to Treaty provisions, this study offers a novel analytical framework for assessing how global health treaties respond to research-identified challenges.

KMKadria Abdel Motaal
Kadria Abdel Motaal
SCSungsoo Chun
Sungsoo Chun
Background: The COVID-19 pandemic exposed major deficiencies in global health governance, including fragmented authority, inequitable resource distribution, and weak compliance mechanisms. Although the WHO Pandemic Agreement (2025) addresses several of these gaps, significant operational and institutional challenges remain. This study aims to develop and empirically validate a Global Governance for Health (GGFH) Framework that strengthens leadership, financing, equity, and legal accountability across global, regional, and national levels. Methods: A three-round Delphi study was conducted. Thirty-one experts from diverse sectors, including public health, international law, economics, environment, and diplomacy, evaluated 32 structured governance statements across seven domains. Experts rated all statements using a 7-point Likert scale. Consensus was determined using a strict threshold median ≥ 6; SD ≤ 1.35; ≥75% agreement. Open-text comments were systematically reviewed through thematic analysis. All statements were systematically mapped to the WHO Pandemic Agreement articles to identify areas lacking operational clarity or enforceability. Results: All seven governance domains achieved consensus by Round 3. High agreement emerged on strengthening WHO leadership, implementing sustainable and equitable financing mechanisms, embedding LMIC representation, establishing legal preparedness and capacity-building, and integrating independent accountability tools. Correlation and interdependence analyses demonstrated that governance goals form an integrated, mutually reinforcing system, with financing, equity, and legal frameworks identified as core enablers of effective treaty implementation. Conclusions: The Delphi process validated a comprehensive and operational Global Governance for Health Framework. The GGFH complements the WHO Pandemic Agreement by addressing its unresolved governance, financing, and equity limitations and offers a structured roadmap to guide global pandemic preparedness and treaty implementation.