Irrigated turfgrass is a major crop in urban areas of the drought-stricken Western United States. A considerable proportion of irrigation water is wasted through the use of conventional sprinkler systems. While smart sprinkler systems have made progress in reducing temporal mis-applications, more research is needed to determine the most appropriate variables for accurately and cost-effectively determining spatial zones for irrigation application. This research uses data from ground and drone surveys of two large sports fields. Surveys were conducted pre-, within and towards the end of the irrigation season to determine spatial irrigation zones. Principal components analysis and k-means classification were used to develop zones using several variables individually and combined. The errors associated with uniform irrigation and different configurations of spatial zones are assessed to determine comparative improvements in irrigation efficiency afforded by spatial irrigation zones. A determination is also made as to whether the spatial zones can be temporally static or need to be re-determined periodically. Results suggest that zones based on spatial soil moisture surveys and simple observations of whether the grass felt wet or dry are better than those based on NDVI, other variables and several variables in combination. In addition, due to the temporal variations observed in spatial patterns, ideally zones should be re-evaluated periodically. However, a less labor-intensive solution is to determine temporally static zones based on patterns in soil moisture averaged from several surveys. Of particular importance are the spatial patterns observed prior to the start of the irrigation season as they reflect more temporally stable variation that relates to soil texture and topography rather than irrigation management.
Turfgrass irrigation consumes a large amount of the scarce freshwater in arid/semi-arid regions. Approximately 50% of this irrigation water is wasted. It has been suggested that determining patterns of spatial variability in soil moisture to modify applications with valve-in-head sprinkler technology can greatly reduce waste. Variable rate irrigation (VRI) studies in traditional agricultural settings have shown that VRI zones do not stay static temporally and need to be frequently redetermined. Electrical conductivity (ECa) data from Geonics EM38 surveys and data from Red, Green, Blue (RGB) and Thermal Infra-Red (Th.IR) drone surveys are less time-consuming and therefore expensive to collect than a dense field survey of soil moisture and grass health to produce accurate geostatistical maps. Drone flights and ECa surveys are compared here for their ability to accurately estimate spatial patterns of soil volumetric water content (VWC) using simple linear regression and z-score transformations for prediction—non-geostatistical approaches that require less data. Overall, ECa readings collected in the horizontal mode were the most consistent at capturing spatial patterns in soil moisture. Predictions from regression produced lower root mean squared errors (RMSEs) for the larger datasets. However, z-score transformation produced lower RMSEs when the sample number was very small and preserved the scale of values better than the regression approach. The results suggested that predictions from ECa and drone data were useful for capturing key features in soil moisture patterns for 2–3 weeks, suggesting that a periodic reassessment of zones is needed. Using ECa and drone data in an urban environment is more labor-intensive than in an agricultural field, so it is likely that automating periodic re-surveying of ECa data for zone definition would only be cost-effective for golf courses or high-income sports fields. Elsewhere, using static zones with variable rates applied to each zone may be more efficient.