Background: Multidisciplinary perinatal care coordination programs support families experiencing complex fetal anomalies during pregnancy. However, little is known about how programs are implemented, sustained, and experienced by providers. To address this gap, we conducted a case study of a longstanding perinatal care coordination program at an academic medical center. Methods: We interviewed 20 providers involved with the Collaborative for Maternal and Infant Health care coordination program at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Respondents included care coordinators, specialty providers, and former and current program leaders. We also reviewed program report documents spanning over 2 decades. Interview and document data were analyzed to identify themes related to program development, operation, impact, challenges, and sustainability. Results: Analysis revealed four main findings. First, care coordinators were consistently described as central to linking prenatal and postnatal care, and providing families with education, emotional support, and coordination across specialties. Second, while multidisciplinary collaboration was viewed as essential, it requires considerable effort and commitment at the organizational level to support shared planning. Third, participants perceived the program as highly valuable for families, providers, and the health system but reported difficulty with measuring success using traditional clinical outcomes. Finally, long-term sustainability is vital but highly challenging in part because of the increasing number of patients and the complexity of cases. Respondents emphasized the importance of institutional support, protected time, clear roles, effective communication systems, and sustainable funding. Conclusions: Effective perinatal care coordination depends on more than just a designated coordinator. Successful programs require organizational structures that support multidisciplinary collaboration, continuity across the prenatal-postnatal continuum, and long-term institutional investment. These findings offer practical guidance for health systems seeking to develop or strengthen perinatal care coordination programs.