Despite the media publicity regarding fire risks, a sharp decline in market size, and safety tests conducted by the Electrical Appliances and Household Appliances Safety Management Laws, electric mats distributed in the market have problems related to fires every year. The causes and problems of the fire were analyzed from the perspective that fire outbreaks may occur. Recall status and defect analysis, fire statistics analysis, recall product sales status investigation, and safety verification experiment for certified products were conducted. Based on a survey of the sales status of recalled products in traditional markets, recalled products were sold in three out of 10 stores, and recalled products were also traded in the secondhand Internet market. For the safety verification experiment, the KC 60335-2-17 standard was applied to 10 safety-certified products sold on the Internet, and major experiments were conducted. The test results showed seven out of 10 products exceeded the standard value. In confirming the identity of the thermostat of the 10 tested products, three showed a difference from the products at the time of actual certification.
This study comparatively analyzed the experimental methods used in previous studies to generate primary and secondary arc beads, with particular emphasis on the conductor temperature conditions. On this basis, the suitability of these methods was critically examined, and the conventional method for generating primary arc beads was considered inconsistent with the definition of a primary arc bead, which should be associated with a short circuit that initiates a fire. To verify this hypothesis, two experiments were conducted. In the first experiment, specimens were generated by short circuiting conductors at room temperature using the same method as in previous studies, and the ability of the resulting arc to ignite adjacent combustible materials was evaluated. In the second experiment, which was designed to produce ignition at the time of the short circuit, a poor electrical connection was first introduced at a receptacle to thermally degrade the combustible material and raise the conductor temperature; a short circuit was then intentionally induced to generate the specimens. The specimens produced in both experiments were prepared and their cross-sectional microstructures were analyzed by scanning electron microscopy–electron backscatter diffraction (SEM-EBSD). Misorientation was quantitatively measured and compared. In the first experiment, cotton was the only combustible material ignited by the arc, whereas in the second experiment, the receptacle insulation ignited when the short circuit occurred. In the comparison of low-angle misorientation in the arc beads generated by the two experiments, the mean values for all specimens from the second experiment were higher than those from the first experiment, and the overall difference between the experiments averaged 32.15%. The t-test results showed a statistically significant difference between the two groups. Furthermore, the standardized mean difference between the two groups was substantial, indicating a clear distinction beyond statistical significance. These results raise questions regarding the representativeness of primary arc bead specimens generated using conventional methods and indicate that the experimental method for generating primary arc beads should be re-established to enable reliable arc bead discrimination.