Nikola Komatina

Dr. Nikola Komatina

Faculty of Engineering University of Kragujevac, Kragujevac, Serbia
orcid
Scientific Associate

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

9Years (2018-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 January 2025 in Spectrum of Mechanical Engineering and Operational Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Nikola KomatinaNikola Komatina
Nikola Komatina
This study examines the application of Multi-Attribute Decision Making (MADM) techniques for selecting an optimal technical solution in the automotive industry, specifically addressing the automatic adjustment and control device of a parking brake cable. The research begins by using the Best-Worst Method (BWM) to determine the weights of criteria, such as device speed, price, weight, and calibration period, based on expert input from maintenance professionals and operators at an automotive original equipment manufacturer in automotive industry. The main objective is to identify the solution that best balances operational efficiency with long-term stability and adaptability to production requirements. In the subsequent phase, both the RADAR method and its modified version, RADAR II, are applied to rank the alternatives. The original RADAR method, which employs ratio-based normalization, tends to favor alternatives that demonstrate stable performance across all criteria, whereas RADAR II, utilizing difference-based normalization, accentuates alternatives that excel in particular aspects. Comparative analysis reveals that although both methods produce generally consistent overall rankings, nuances in the normalization process can lead to differences in the relative prominence of certain solutions. Sensitivity analysis further confirms the robustness and reliability of these approaches, underscoring the importance of selecting a method that aligns with the specific decision-making context. Ultimately, the study demonstrates that a carefully tailored MADM approach, integrating both RADAR and RADAR II techniques, provides valuable insights and supports effective decision-making in complex industrial environments.

1 December 2024 in Jurnal Sistem dan Manajemen Industri
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
Nikola KomatinaNikola Komatina
Nikola Komatina
Multi-Attribute Decision-Making (MADM) methods are essential in decision-making processes, particularly in solving problems related to ranking and classifying alternatives. Among the MADM methods frequently utilized in the literature for ranking alternatives are distance-based or compromise-based methods. These methods have been widely applied for decades, with ongoing development leading to new approaches. One such approach is RAnking, based on the Distances And Range (RADAR) method. This novel distance-based method evaluates alternatives by considering their distance relative to the best and worst alternative values for a given criterion and the range between them. This paper applies the RADAR method to rank failure modes identified through a standard Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) in an automotive industry company that produces rubber and plastic products. The results obtained from the RADAR method are compared with those derived from the traditional Risk Priority Number (RPN) approach. The comparison demonstrates that the RADAR method provides more distinct rankings, reducing the occurrence of ties between alternatives and thus offering a more nuanced and reliable decision-making tool in the context of failure mode prioritization.

12 September 2019 in Journal of Intelligent & Fuzzy Systems: Applications in Engineering and Technology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
GÐGoran Ðurić
Goran Ðurić
ČMČaslav Mitrović
Časlav Mitrović
Nikola KomatinaNikola Komatina
Nikola Komatina
DTDanijela Tadić
Danijela Tadić
GVGoran Vorotović
Goran Vorotović
Evaluation and analysis of failures which occur in the products or services in different economic areas are an important task of operational management. Solution of this problem leads to the increase of product’s/service’s quality, but in the same time it also increases business processes effectiveness and business goal’s realization. The treated problem is especially important in the information technologies domain. In this paper, the risk factors that may cause failures of the software are defined in compliance with the Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (FMEA) framework and they are assessed during the development and the maintenance phase. The relative importance of these risk factors and their values at the level of each identified failure are described by pre-defined linguistic terms which are modelled by the interval type-2 trapezoidal fuzzy numbers (IT2TrFNs). The weights vector is calculated by using the Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (FAHP) with interval type-2 fuzzy sets. The rank of failures is obtained by using the complex proportional assessment (COPRAS) method. The example with real life data is illustrated to demonstrate the potential and applicability of the adopted methods.

26 September 2022 in Expert Systems
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
Aleksandar AleksicAleksandar Aleksic
Aleksandar Aleksic
DMDragan D. Milanović
Dragan D. Milanović
Nikola KomatinaNikola Komatina
Nikola Komatina
DTDanijela Tadić
Danijela Tadić

6 May 2022 in Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part O: Journal of Risk and Reliability
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
Nikola KomatinaNikola Komatina
Nikola Komatina
DTDanijela Tadić
Danijela Tadić
AAAleksandar Aleksić
Aleksandar Aleksić
AJAleksandar D Jovanović
Aleksandar D Jovanović
The selection of appropriate suppliers in an uncertain environment influences the sustainability and the competitive advantage of the automotive industry and hence presents one of the significant management problems. In the literature, it is suggested that an acceptable supplier may be determined concerning many criteria. In this manuscript, criteria selection is based on the relevant literature. Handling of different uncertainties is performed by using the type-2 fuzzy sets that have the capability of handling more considered impreciseness and uncertainties. In the presented research, the two-state model is proposed. In the first stage, the relative importance of criteria and sub-criteria are described by pre-defined linguistic expressions which are modeled by the interval type-2 triangular fuzzy numbers (IT2TFNs). The fuzzy weights vectors are given by using the fuzzy Analytic Hierarchical Process with IT2TFNs (IT2FAHP). After that, the ranking of suppliers is based on the modified Multi-Attributive Border Approximation area Comparison method (MABAC) with IT2TFNs (IT2FMABAC). The extension of the conventional MABAC includes: (a) modeling of sub-criteria values of IT2TFNs, (b) the fuzzy criteria values are calculated by using fuzzy algebra rules, (c) belonging of each supplier to border approximation areas (BAAs) is given by using procedure, and (d) the distance of suppliers to BAAs is determined by using the normalized Euclidean distance formulas. The proposed model is tested on the real-life data from the automotive supply chain. Through the presented research, it is shown that the proposed IT2FMABAC is a useful and reliable tool for the rational purchasing decision-making process.

27 July 2021 in Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile Engineering
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
Nikola KomatinaNikola Komatina
Nikola Komatina
DTDanijela Tadić
Danijela Tadić
AAAleksandar Aleksić
Aleksandar Aleksić
NBNikola Banduka
Nikola Banduka
The change of market’s demand could be predictable to a certain degree at stable conditions but it may vary due to disruptive events. This research contributes by establishing the improvement of PFMEA (Process Failure Mode and Effect Analysis) analysis in the domain of assessment and determining severity risk factor, as well as identifying of failure priority. According to the researchers’ and practitioners’ suggestions, severity needs to be considered from the multiple aspects. The risk factor severity is considered from the aspects of product importance, quality, and cost. These aspects have different relative importance, which is determined in an exact way. The relative importance of the aspects, as well as the values of the risk factors, was described by linguistic expressions that are modeled by using the Interval type-2 trapezoidal fuzzy numbers (IT2TrFNs). IT2FBWM was used to determine weight vectors of risk factors. The priority of failures is determined according to the Action priority model which proposed by AIAG & VDA (Automotive Industry Action Group and German Association of the Automotive Industry). The proposed methodology is tested in a Case study where the real-life data originated from a company from the Republic of Serbia that operates as a part of an automotive supply chain.