Correlations between the structural properties and nonradiative recombination (NRR) behaviors of threading dislocations in freestanding hydride-vapor-phase-epitaxy (HVPE) GaN substrates were investigated using cathodoluminescence (CL), the etch pit method, transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and multiple-photon excitation photoluminescence (MPPL). A statistical analysis with a one-to-one comparison of 480 CL dark spots (prior to etching) with their corresponding etch pits shows that all dislocation types act as NRR centers with a strong correlation between the NRR rate at the dislocation cores and the pit size. Further TEM observations accurately determined the magnitude and direction of Burgers vectors for dislocations under each type of etch pit, which firmly links the NRR behaviors with the dislocation type. It is found that a dislocation pair composed of (a + c) and (−a + c) threading mixed-type dislocations (TMDs) is the strongest NRR center among the considered dislocation types. The pair runs along the c-axis with a stable distance of 42 nm between them. This is followed by other types of TMD pairs, a + c TMDs, ma + nc TMDs (m and n are integers, m > 1 or n > 1), 1c threading screw dislocations, and 1a threading edge dislocations in descending order of NRR rates. Three-dimensional (3D) dislocation images visualized by MPPL revealed that most of the dislocations are nearly parallel to the c-axis, while the a + c TMDs are susceptible to large tilting. MPPL also indicates that the ma + nc TMDs may result from several merging dislocations.
This paper describes a mechanism to explain the lattice bowing of freestanding GaN substrates grown by hydride vapor phase epitaxy on sapphire substrates. The freestanding GaN substrates typically exhibit a concave shape. It is revealed that the radius of curvature and lattice constant of the top surface are almost the same as those of the bottom surface. This is indicative of the complete relaxation of the GaN lattice, even though the freestanding GaN substrate exhibited a curvature. It is shown that dislocations are present in a plane normal to the growth direction in addition to conventionally known threading dislocations; these are referred to as in-plane dislocations. Based on these results, it is proven quantitatively that the extra-half planes related to the in-plane dislocations are primarily responsible for the phenomenon of lattice bowing.