Previous research on the flexible structure of flapping wings has shown an improved propulsion performance in comparison to rigid wings. However, not much is known about this function in terms of power efficiency modification for flapping wing energy devices. In order to study the role of the flexible wing deformation in the hydrodynamics of flapping wing energy devices, we computationally model the two-dimensional flexible single and twin flapping wings in operation under the energy extraction conditions with a large Reynolds number of 106. The flexible motion for the present study is predetermined based on a priori structural result which is different from a passive flexibility solution. Four different models are investigated with additional potential local distortions near the leading and trailing edges. Our simulation results show that the flexible structure of a wing is beneficial to enhance power efficiency by increasing the peaks of lift force over a flapping cycle, and tuning the phase shift between force and velocity to a favourable trend. Moreover, the impact of wing flexibility on efficiency is more profound at a low nominal effective angle of attack (AoA). At a typical flapping frequency f * = 0.15 and nominal effective AoA of 10°, a flexible integrated wing generates 7.68% higher efficiency than a rigid wing. An even higher increase, around six times that of a rigid wing, is achievable if the nominal effective AoA is reduced to zero degrees at feathering condition. This is very attractive for a semi-actuated flapping energy system, where energy input is needed to activate the pitching motion. The results from our dual-wing study found that a parallel twin-wing device can produce more power compared to a single wing due to the strong flow interaction between the two wings.
It is well known that structural flexibility enhances the performance of flapping foil propellers. There is, however, much less knowledge about the effect of deformability on the flow energy extraction capacity of flapping foils. Following recent work on an oscillating foil energy harvesting device with prescribed foil deformations (Liu et al., “A Bio-Inspired Study on Tidal Energy Extraction with Flexible Flapping Wings,” Bioinspiration and Biomimetics, Vol. 8, No. 3, 2013, Paper 036011), fully coupled dynamics of a flapping foil energy harvester with a passively deformable foil is investigated. Toward this end, the dynamics of a foil with a realistic internal structure (containing a rigid leading edge and a flexible trailing edge with a stiffener) in an energy harvesting regime through a fluid–structure interaction scheme is computationally studied. To examine the effect of different levels of flexibility, various materials (ranging from metals such as copper to virtual materials with arbitrary elasticity and density) for the stiffener have been tested. With the virtual materials, the effects of Young’s modulus and density ratio have been studied. The simulation results show that flexibility around the trailing edge could enhance the overall energy extraction performance. For example, with a copper stiffener, an increase of 32.2% in efficiency can be reached at high reduced frequency. The performance enhancement is achieved mostly in cases with low Young’s modulus and density ratio. A possible underlying mechanism is that the specific foil deformations in these cases encourage the generation and shedding of vortices from the foil leading edge, which is known to be beneficial to flow energy extraction.