Descriptions of a dynamic warning system usually assign the system certain diagnostic values. Operators should adjust their responses to these values when considering the output of the system for their decisions. This approach is not necessarily appropriate for complex systems that are controlled by human operators. Here the operators' actions are likely to change the frequency of events that should trigger a warning. Consequently the operator will change the predictive value of a warning system that is imperfectly correlated with the monitored events. In general its diagnostic value decreases for better operators. This phenomenon is demonstrated on the example of binary warnings about binary events, and an empirical demonstration of the phenomenon is provided in an experimental study of a process control task. Actual or potential applications of this research include improved understanding of the determinants of operators'responses to warnings, which should help in the design of better warning systems.
Problem: Labelling of high-risk drug infusions and lines is a well-recognised safety strategy to prevent medication errors. Although hospital wards characterised by multiple high-risk drug infusions use different types of labelling, little is known about the contribution of a colour-coded label (CCL) to patient safety. Setting: A quality improvement programme audit at a tertiary care facility, the Hadassah University Medical Center Ein Kerem, Jerusalem, Israel. Strategy for change: A CCL for intravenous (IV) high-risk medications and lines was designed to promote safer medication administration at the intensive care unit bedside and in other acute wards. Methods: The purpose of the study was to compare a new CCL method (intervention) with the current labelling method (control). Laboratory simulation, imitating an intensive care unit, was designed. Safety of the medication treatment and overall duration of nurses’ orientation with drugs and lines at the patient’s bedside were measured. Effects of change: The use of the new CCL improved proper identification of IV bags (p<0.0001), reduced the time required for description of overall drugs and lines (p = 0.04), improved identification of errors at the treatment setting—drugs and lines (p = 0.03) and reduced the average performance time for overall tasks (p<0.0001). Lessons learnt: The use of CCLs for IV high-risk medications and lines can improve patient safety and improve medical staff efficiency.
Two experiments assessed the effect of various static and dynamic computer 'wait' message displays on (1) subjective estimates of the duration of intervals during which a subject had to wait for the computer's response, and (2) subjective preferences among the different displays. All the static displays led to identical duration estimates. For dynamic displays a direct relation between the rate of changes and the estimate was found. Faster rates led in most cases to increased estimates of duration, and slow-changing graphic displays appeared to have the shortest duration. Subjects preferred epigrams to all other displays, and cumulative graphic displays to a blinking or static WAIT. The rate of change did not affect preference ratings for the graphic displays, whereas slower blink rates were preferred for the WAIT. The results demonstrate that the findings and models from earlier basic research on time estimation are relevant for predicting the subjective assessment of wait-periods. However, users' satisfaction with the displays depends not only on the apparent duration of the wait period, but also on other variables. These should be considered when choosing the display that is shown while users wait for the system to complete a task.
6 April 2019 in Journal of Clinical Monitoring and Computing
Operators often need to combine self-initiated and respondent actions. Two experiments dealt with the relative importance of these two types of actions as a function of the predictability of the system and the available information. Participants monitored three stations with different frequencies at which interventions were required. They were aided by warning cues, indicating the need for interventions. The frequencies of inspections of the stations, the response to the warning system and the overall performance were assessed for warning systems with different diagnostic properties. Participants adapted their responses to the relative frequency of required interventions and the reliance on and compliance to the warning system depended on the warning characteristics. The results support the notion that events, such as warning signals, have a complex role in the ongoing activity of the operator and are integrated into the set of information from external and internal sources that guide the operators' actions.