Smallholders constitute more than three quarters of the world’s farmers, and despite their numbers, they commonly lack opportunities to advance their development status. Bioenergy production and consumption can help sustain smallholders’ energy needs and generate employment and income, but it also raises concerns over social justice and equity, especially where crops used for bioenergy could also be used for food. This perspective paper is grounded in a literature review related to three different crops in Brazil: sugarcane, landrace maize and sweet potato. It seeks to determine if these crops offer the potential to support smallholder farmers’ development in a more equitable way, focusing on opportunities for their use in bioenergy. We review the literature to identify policies shaping the smallholder development context in relation to these crops, assessing whose knowledge informs policy and institutional decision making, and highlighting the policy attention afforded to the different crops from different sectors. We further evaluate the literature on each crop in relation to water use and calorific value (i.e., food and energy). Our review indicates that while sugarcane has received the most policy and institutional attention, its development is largely anchored in research and development investments that support large-scale commercial farms and agri-businesses. Smallholders have not benefited or had the opportunity to engage in relevant policy decision making for sugarcane cultivation. At the same time, smallholders hold valuable untapped knowledge on the cultivation of sweet potato and landrace maize, both of which have the potential to generate development opportunities for smallholders. Our review suggests that the environmental impact of landrace maize and sweet potato in terms of water use is significantly lower than sugarcane, while they can generate more calories for energy or food consumption and offer diversification opportunities. Despite that these alternative crops offer considerable untapped potential to support rural development, more research is still needed to harness these benefits. Changes are needed to address inequities in policies, institutions and the types of knowledge informing decision making. Such changes need to afford smallholder farmers greater recognition and participation in decision making, so that the distribution of benefits from the three study crops can reach them to support their development better.
Scientific data and tools are increasingly developed to support evidence‐based environmental management decisions. However, they are not always used by lay stakeholders (i.e., non‐scientist policy actors and agricultural producers) to support decisions. Scientific tools such as groundwater models provide a simplified representation of physical systems but can be highly technical and results include a level of uncertainty. A primary influence on someone's evaluation and use of scientific information is their trust in science and scientists. In this article, we explore the role that trust in groundwater models and the modelers who create them plays in model evaluation and use. We draw on 22 interviews with agricultural producers, water policy actors and modelers who are affected by or work with a numerical groundwater flow model developed for the Equus Beds Groundwater Management District in Kansas, USA. We compare different user groups' perceptions of model accuracy, salience and uncertainty and then assess key dimensions of perceived modeler trustworthiness, specifically, their ability, integrity and benevolence. We find an overall high level of trust among experienced water policy actors and agricultural producers in both models and modelers, despite acknowledgement of model uncertainty. Agricultural producers' perceptions of modelers are shaped by concerns about their perceived integrity, followed by benevolence, while for water policy actors, ability and integrity are primary concerns. Our findings suggest that modelers should be aware of the information needs and expectations of model users to increase model usability. Modelers should also be transparent and clearly communicate uncertainties and limitations in model outputs to allow model users to weigh potential implications themselves.