Open-ended coaxial line probes (OCs) are systematically analyzed by means of numerical 3-D finite element calculations in combination with experimental investigations for microwave dielectric spectroscopy on fine grained soils. The probes, based on conventional coaxial lines and connectors (N, SMA), are broadband characterized in the frequency range from 1 MHz to 10 GHz. The sensitive region for dielectric measurements is ±7-mm lateral and 7-mm perpendicular to the midpoint of the sensor aperture. The spatial spreading of the sensitive zone is stable for the investigated low-loss and high-loss strongly dispersive standard liquids, as well as the saturated and unsaturated soils. Dielectric spectra are determined based on a bilinear relationship between effective permittivity and complex reflection coefficient of the probe after probe-calibration with known standards. The mean relative error of the real part of the complex permittivity from 100 MHz to 10 GHz is smaller than 3.5% and is less than 10% for the imaginary part. A lower limit of the measurement range of 50 MHz with the used procedure and materials is suggested. Complex effective permittivity of saturated fine-grained soils is determined with the developed probes and procedure. The soil dielectric spectra were analyzed with a broadband relaxation model, as well as a novel, coupled hydraulic-dielectric mixture approach. The results demonstrate the suitability of the investigated OCs for the determination of high resolution soil dielectric spectra.
We combined two completely different methods measuring the frequency-dependent electrical properties of moist porous materials in order to receive an extraordinary large frequency spectrum. In the low-frequency (LF) range, complex electrical resistivity between 1 mHz and 45 kHz was measured for three different soils and sandstone, using the spectral induced polarization (SIP) method with a four electrode cell. In the high-frequency (HF) radio to microwave range, complex dielectric permittivity was measured between 1 MHz and 10 GHz for the same samples using dielectric spectroscopy by means of the coaxial transmission line technique. The combined data sets cover 13 orders of magnitude and were transferred into their equivalent expressions: the complex effective dielectric permittivity and the complex effective electrical conductivity. We applied the Kramers-Kronig relation in order to justify the validity of the data combination. A new phenomenological model that consists of both dielectric permittivity and electrical conductivity terms in a Debye- and Cole–Cole-type manner was fitted to the spectra. The combined permittivity and conductivity model accounts for the most common representations of the physical quantities with respect to the individual measuring method. A maximum number of four relaxation processes was identified in the analysed frequency range. Among these are the free water and different interfacial relaxation processes, the Maxwell-Wagner effect, the counterion relaxation in the electrical double layer and the direct-current electrical conductivity. There is evidence that free water relaxation does not affect the electrical response in the SIP range. Moreover, direct current conductivity contribution (bulk and interface) dominates the losses in the HF range. Interfacial relaxation processes with relaxations in the HF range are broadly distributed down to the LF range. The slowest observed process in the LF range has a minor contribution to the HF response.
High-frequency electromagnetic determination of moisture in porous media, (e.g., soil) is based on the strong relationship between volumetric water content and relative dielectric permittivity. In particular, in fine-grained soils the movement of water is influenced by different surface-bonding forces due to interface processes. The interface effects lead to a number of dielectric relaxation processes (free- and bound-water phase, Maxwell–Wagner effect, counterion relaxation effects). These relaxation processes are the reason for the strong frequency dependence of the electromagnetic material properties below 1 GHz. The matric potential is a measure of the bonding forces on water in the soil. Based on a thermodynamic relationship between soil matric potential and dielectric relaxation behaviour of water in different binding states, a broadband dielectric relaxation model was developed that considers low-frequency dispersion up to 1 MHz as well as losses due to direct-current conductivity. The sensitivity of the model on soil suction was systematically analyzed based on a pedotransfer function (PTF) for soil textures ranging from pure sand up to pure clay. The results are compared with known empirical and semiempirical calibration functions, as well as theoretical mixing models.
22 August 2013 in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
Water content is a key parameter to monitor in nuclear waste repositories such as the planed underground repository in Bure, France, in the Callovo‐Oxfordian (COx) clay formation. High‐frequency electromagnetic (HF‐EM) measurement techniques, i.e., time or frequency domain reflectometry, offer useful tools for quantitative estimation of water content in porous media. However, despite the efficiency of HF‐EM methods, the relationship between water content and dielectric material properties needs to be characterized. Moreover, the high amount of swelling clay in the COx clay leads to dielectric relaxation effects which induce strong dispersion coupled with high absorption of EM waves. Against this background, the dielectric relaxation behavior of the clay rock was studied at frequencies from 1 MHz to 10 GHz with network analyzer technique in combination with coaxial transmission line cells. For this purpose, undisturbed and disturbed clay rock samples were conditioned to achieve a water saturation range from 0.16 to nearly saturation. The relaxation behavior was quantified based on a generalized fractional relaxation model under consideration of an apparent direct current conductivity assuming three relaxation processes: a high‐frequency water process and two interface processes which are related to interactions between the aqueous pore solution and mineral particles (adsorbed/hydrated water relaxation, counter ion relaxation and Maxwell‐Wagner effects). The frequency‐dependent HF‐EM properties were further modeled based on a novel hydraulic‐mechanical‐electromagnetic coupling approach developed for soils. The results show the potential of HF‐EM techniques for quantitative monitoring of the hydraulic state in underground repositories in clay formations.