The per-operative assessment of primary stem stability may help to improve the performance of total hip replacement. Vibration analysis methods have been successfully used to assess dental implant stability, to monitor fracture healing and to measure bone mechanical properties. The objective of the present study was to evaluate in vivo a vibration analysis-based endpoint criterion for the insertion of the stem by successive surgeon-controlled hammer blows.
In total hip replacement (THR) a good initial stability of the prosthetic stem in the femur, which corresponds to a good overall initial contact, will help assure a good long-term result. During the insertion the implant stability increases and, as a consequence, the resonance frequencies increase, allowing the assessment of the implant fixation by vibration analysis. The influence of changing contact conditions on the resonance frequencies was however not yet quantitatively understood and therefore a finite element analysis (FEA) was set up. Modal analyses on the hip stem-femur system were performed in various contact situations. By modelling the contact changes by means of the contact tolerance options in the finite element software, contact could be varied over the entire hip stem surface or only in specific zones (proximal, central, distal) while keeping other system parameters constant. The results are in agreement with previous observations: contact increase causes positive resonance frequency shifts and the dynamic behaviour is most influenced by contact changes in the proximal zone. Although the finite element analysis did not establish a monotonous relationship between the vibrational mode number and the magnitude of the resonance frequency shift, in general the higher modes are more sensitive to the contact change.
In cementless total hip arthroplasty (THA), the initial stability is obtained by press-fitting the implant in the bone to allow osseointegration for a long term secondary stability. However, finding the insertion endpoint that corresponds to a proper initial stability is currently based on the tactile and auditory experiences of the orthopedic surgeon, which can be challenging. This study presents a novel real-time method based on acoustic signals to monitor the acetabular implant fixation in cementless total hip arthroplasty. Twelve acoustic in vitro experiments were performed on three types of bone models; a simple bone block model, an artificial pelvic model and a cadaveric model. A custom made beam was screwed onto the implant which functioned as a sound enhancer and insertor. At each insertion step an acoustic measurement was performed. A significant acoustic resonance frequency shift was observed during the insertion process for the different bone models; 250 Hz (35%, second bending mode) to 180 Hz (13%, fourth bending mode) for the artificial bone block models and 120 Hz (11%, eighth bending mode) for the artificial pelvis model. No significant frequency shift was observed during the cadaveric experiment due to a lack of implant fixation in this model. This novel diagnostic method shows the potential of using acoustic signals to monitor the implant seating during insertion.
1 February 2017 in Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials
Modal parameters are often investigated in order to assess the initial fixation of an implant. Most of studies are focused on the natural frequencies and frequency response function. Usually the femoral stem is tested although the acetabular cup fixation is important as well. The results of implant stability assessment are inconsistent and seem to suggest that frequency as a stability indicator is not sufficiently sensitive. In this study the sensitivity of the modal properties to changes in the bone-implant interface was investigated with the help of the finite element method (FEM). A novel fixation index based on modal shape curvature was investigated as a potential measure of the implant fixation. Modal frequencies are sensitive to interface changes in some manner, but suffer from insensitivity to local changes at bone-implant interface. The sensitivity up to 44% of natural frequencies to stiffness change due insertion steps was observed. The tested damage indicators are able to detect localized small changes in peripheral stiffness (5% stiffness reduction) with 95% confidence under the noise up to 1%. The modal shapes and their curvatures have a great potential to be a robust fixation indicator.