In January 2019, the People’s Armed Police set up a working group to draft the Coast Guard Law of the People’s Republic of China. The 13th National People’s Congress Standing Committee concluded its twenty-fifth session and scrutiny of this draft law, which officially entered force on 1 February 2021. The Law is divided into 11 chapters and 80 articles, including but not limited to maritime security, maritime crime investigation, use of non-firearm and weapons, and international cooperation. This article outlines and analyses the Law, as well as focusing on its implications as a matter of international law.
For the international judicial bodies constituted under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), there are mainly three conditions which limit their jurisdiction to extend to disputes pertaining to the interpretation and application of UNCLOS which involve sovereignty issue: firstly, if the nature of the dispute is deemed as a sovereignty dispute; secondly, if the prerequisite to adjudicate/arbitrate the dispute is to resolve the sovereignty dispute; and thirdly, if the adjudication/arbitration of the dispute will advance or detract a state’s sovereignty claim. However, not all disputes involving territorial sovereignty are out of their jurisdiction. Provided that the court judgment or arbitral award will not affect the settlement of the sovereignty dispute between the disputed states or the claim to sovereignty of any state, they may, to a certain extent, have jurisdiction over a dispute of the interpretation and application of UNCLOS with sovereignty dispute ancillary to it.
Against the backdrop of the COVID-19 outbreak onboard the cruise ship Diamond Princess, both the flag State and the port State should act according to international obligations during the sailing stage, quarantine period after ships’ berthing, and the time when the quarantine period expires. However, the potential danger of the absence of a “genuine link” between the cruise shipowners and the flag State, the lack of coordination of jurisdiction in different sea areas and between different States, and also the lack of special or systematic regulations for infection prevention and control (IPC) at sea and for cruise ships increase the risk of a State’s breach of international obligations. Therefore, it is deemed necessary to improve the responsive measures in international law. This paper, after review and analysis, sheds light on various recommendations on how to improve the responsive measures in international law, including (i) strengthening of the jurisdiction of the flag State, (ii) establishment of a special international cooperation mechanism with an alliance between the WHO and the IMO, and (iii) construction of an IPC mechanism for home ports of cruise ships.
The EU has introduced a series of shipping carbon emissions regulations, including the MRV, the EU ETS, and FuelEU Maritime, thereby establishing a port-centric extraterritorial regulatory framework by clearly defining the scope, objectives, and modalities of extraterritorial application. The EU’s maritime carbon emissions regime draws on the theoretical foundations of port state control and territorial extension and, combined with the EU’s dominant position in the global shipping market, enables the exercise of extraterritorial jurisdiction over carbon emissions generated during voyages outside EU waters by vessels calling at or transiting through EU ports. At the same time, an exemption mechanism has been designed to mitigate conflicts arising from such extraterritorial application. The extraterritorial application of EU shipping carbon emissions legislation has triggered disputes over jurisdictional legitimacy, placing pressure on the IMO by weakening its authority and contributing to regulatory fragmentation. It has also intensified divergences between developed and developing States regarding the regulation of shipping carbon emissions with extraterritorial effects. In response to the extraterritorial application of the EU shipping carbon emissions legislation, there are two paths that China can adopt. About the adaptive tools, firstly, it is valuable to add port State jurisdiction over shipping carbon emissions to domestic legislation and strive for equivalent mutual recognition of allowances with the EU ETS. Secondly, efforts can be made to promote the cooperation on the green transition of the shipping industry between the shipping enterprises of China and the EU. About the defensive tools, firstly, on the basis of supporting CBDR, China can collaborate with developing states to promote the development of multilateral governance mechanisms under the IMO and adopt countermeasures when necessary. Secondly, China can activate domestic blocking legislation to prohibit the unjustified extraterritorial application of EU legislations, and establish accompanying compensation mechanisms to safeguard national and enterprises’ interests.