Purpose: This paper proposes to apply the lean philosophy principle of minimizing or eliminating non-value adding activities combined with 4D building information modeling (BIM) simulations to reduce transportation waste in construction production processes.Design/methodology/approach: This study adopts design science research (DSR) because of its prescriptive character to produce innovative constructions (artifacts) to solve real-world problems. The artifact proposed is a set of constructs for evaluating the utility of 4D BIM simulations for transportation waste reduction. The authors performed two learning cycles using empirical studies in projects A, B and C. The construction process of cast-in-place (CIP) reinforcement concrete (RC) was selected to demonstrate and evaluate 4D BIM's utility. The empirical studies focused on understanding the current transportation waste, collecting actual performance data during job site visits and demonstrating the usage of 4D BIM.Findings: In the first cycle, 4D BIM successfully allowed users to understand the CIP-RC process's transportation activities, which were modeled. In the second cycle, 4D BIM enabled better decision-making processes concerning the definitions of strategies for placing reusable formworks for CIP concrete walls by planning transportation activities.Practical implications: In Cycle 2, three different scenarios were simulated to identify the most suitable formwork assembly planning, and the results were compared to the real situations identified during the job site visits. The scenario chosen demonstrated that the 4D BIM simulation yielded an 18.75% cycle time reduction. In addition, the simulation contributed to a decrease in transportation waste that was previously identified.Originality/value: The original contribution of this paper is the use of 4D BIM simulation for managing non-value adding activities to reduce transportation waste. The utility of 4D BIM for the reduction of those conflicts considered three constructs: (1) the capacity to improve transportation activity efficiency, (2) the capacity to improve construction production efficiency and (3) the capacity to reduce transportation waste consequences.
This study is part of an ongoing research project aiming to develop a method for understanding workers’ efficiency (workers’ time spent in value-adding activities) by measuring new indexes, such as workers’ travelled distances and workers’ locations collected by smartwatches. To achieve the objective of the study, a Design Science Research (DSR) strategy was adopted. The first cycle consists of understanding which types of information smartwatches can collect and how this data can be employed for measuring workers’ efficiency. This paper reports a case study as part of the first Cycle of the DSR. The object studied were the activities carried out by a carpenter trade in a housing renovation project. The authors used the geographic coordinates obtained by smartwatches worn by the carpenter trade connected to two Global Navigations Satellite Systems. The primary contribution of this research consists of proposing a set of five guidelines for the application of smartwatches, using data gathered from the case study. The guidelines are: (1) adopt a stratified sampling approach for selecting the workers involved according to their tasks conducted; (2) set up the smartwatches considering workers’ physical features; (3) carefully consider the job site location for delivering the smartwatch to workers; (4) establish assumptions for the data cleaning process regarding construction project features and the study’s goal; and (5) use individual participant data in the analysis according to each participant’s characteristics and role.
Resumo Este artigo tem como objetivo apresentar o processo de identificação, mensuração e caracterização das perdas por transporte nos fluxos físicos de processos construtivos, considerando suas incidências, tempos, causas e consequências. A abordagem metodológica adotada foi Design Science Research, desenvolvida a partir de dois estudos de caso em processos ainda poucos empregados no Brasil, quais sejam, revestimento com argamassa projetada e Light Steel Frame. Esses estudos foram conduzidos a partir das etapas de identificação dos fluxos físicos, identificação da distribuição dos tempos dos trabalhadores e caracterização das perdas por transporte. Múltiplas fontes de evidências, ferramentas e técnicas foram utilizadas para a organização dos eventos de perda por transporte, associados a suas causas e consequências. Os resultados obtidos indicaram que a maior parte das perdas por transporte foram ocasionadas por problemas de mobilidade dentro do canteiro. Problemas causados pela falta de equipamentos apropriados foram os que mais perda de tempo ocasionaram. A redução das condições de segurança e a necessidade de um novo transporte foram as principais consequências observadas. As principais contribuições deste estudo estão relacionadas ao maior entendimento da natureza das perdas por transporte, à adoção de ferramentas e indicadores para a caracterização das perdas por transporte do ponto de vista de sua incidência e tempos, bem como uma proposta de classificação das principais causas e consequências para a caracterização dessas perdas.
1 May 2023 in Journal of Engineering, Project, and Production Management
The Work Sampling (WS) technique, used worldwide to understand how workers spend their time, represents a time-consuming and costly activity. Therefore, several researchers work on different approaches to automate the data collection using sensor-based and vision-based technologies. The challenge of all the sensor-based approaches is that they do not provide the share of time in different work categories. The lack of knowledge on a possible correlation between Direct Work and, e.g., presence, location, or worker movement represents a gap in the current body of knowledge. Thus, this research aims to understand the correlation between Direct Work as the independent predictor variable; and Movement as the dependent response variable. The authors used the data gathered through the application of WS in five case studies on building renovation projects in Denmark. To explain this correlation. The authors selected a combination of four quantitative techniques: (1) curve estimation; (2) linear regression; (3) ANOVA analysis; and (4) t-test. The correlation of the result is discussed considering three assumptions: (1) the structure of the day; (2) global vs. local; and (3) Movement vs. Transporting and Walking. The result shows a significant correlation between Direct Work and Movement with an average R 2 of 0.328. This is considered acceptable predictability taking the socio-technical system aspect of a construction site into account.
This study is part of an ongoing research project that aims to understand workers' job satisfaction in the construction industry. For that, a survey was applied among construction workers in Denmark. This paper aims to identify the impact of Lean Construction on job satisfaction. Data from 2176 responses were analysed using framework analysis, shorting the answers into three categories: Lean knowledge; Lean application; and Lean operation, even though they declared not knowing Lean. The study investigated the impact of the different levels of Lean familiarity on job satisfaction within five aspects: Project progress; Management-employee relationship; Employee work monitoring; Workload; and Workflow. Findings indicate that only 15% of respondents have some knowledge of Lean concepts, with only 8% confirming its application. The strongest correlation (R 2 =0.557) was found between the Lean practice of "organization attempt to keep workers informed" and the job satisfaction factor of "manager-worker relationship". Allowing the workers to evolve and improve presented, also, a strong correlation with job satisfaction. The study highlights that Lean practices that lead or require Respect for People are the aspects that impact the most on job satisfaction. The results emphasize that implementing Lean principles effectively matters more than merely being familiar with them.
This study examines Location-Based Work Sampling (LBWS) to improve construction site management by identifying workflow issues. For that, a Case Study was conducted on a Danish new building project, and the workflows of three trades were observed. The LBWS application presented a structured four-step methodology: (1) activity and workspace identification; (2) data collection; (3) data visualization; and (4) data analysis. For the LBWS application, the "Ajour system" app was selected as the optimal software based on the technique "Choosing by Advantages". At the data collection step, the authors registered 994 random observations of worker activities classified into six work activity categories (production, preparation, transportation, walking, talking, and waiting) and into four workspace categories (production, preparation, storage, and transportation workspace). Previous LBWS studies used a single workspace categorization. This study introduces a grid-based system to capture production dynamics. This study highlights LBWS as a powerful tool for optimizing workflows by identifying inefficiencies. It provides insights into (1) work activity analysis, differentiating value-added vs. non-value-added tasks, reducing excessive walking and waiting times; (2) workspace and resource utilization, using heat maps to assess labor and material distribution; and (3) interferences and congestion, identifying workflow bottlenecks caused by overcrowding or mismanagement.