Following the industrial revolution, major economic and populational growth took place, and, therefore, solid waste generation increased exponentially. Nowadays, waste management still generates major impacts because the current wide offer of waste management strategies includes many solutions that produce suboptimal results, such as landfill or waste incineration. From a circular economy perspective, composting is a potentially sustainable option to treat the organic fraction of solid waste and has the advantage of recycling many organic compounds that can be reintroduced into the natural processes. This study aimed to provide a meta-analysis using the Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) method to evaluate the impacts of composting by performing a systematic literature review of the diversity of approaches and assessing environmental impacts. The results of the impact assessment were highly dependent on the choices made over the system boundary and the functional units. The most cited environmental impacts were Global Warming Potential, Acidification Potential, Eutrophication Potential, Photochemical Oxidation Potential, and Ozone Layer Depletion, as gaseous emissions from the transport and decomposition represent the main contributors to these categories. Using a smaller dataset and evaluating the use of the CML method and the most cited impacts categories, it was found that In-vessel Composting and Home Composting were considered the best environmental options among the studied composting methods. Composting environmental impacts were also highly related to the use of non-renewable energy sources, which puts composting at a disadvantage when compared with the use of anaerobic digestion. Such results emphasize the benefits of using these waste management technologies as complementary instead of substitutes.
27 March 2025 in Waste Management & Research: The Journal for a Sustainable Circular Economy
Biowaste is an increasingly relevant environmental issue worldwide, causing significant environmental, economic and social impacts. Effective strategies are crucial to mitigate impacts, maximising biowaste’s valorisation. This article presents a systematic literature review on using life cycle assessment (LCA) to evaluate municipal biowaste treatment facilities. The primary objective was to analyse how LCA is applied to assess the environmental efficiency of mechanical and biological treatment involving composting and anaerobic digestion (AD)-based systems. The article addressed the methodological heterogeneity across previous LCA studies, identifying critical gaps and challenges regarding standardisation and result comparability. It underscores the importance of accurately considering environmental indicators and emission factors, as these significantly affect overall LCA outcomes. Results show that most publications focus on Europe and Asia, highlighting a research gap in regions like Africa. The organic fraction municipal solid waste is the predominant feedstock, and 1 tonne of biowaste was the frequently used functional unit, reflecting the upstream impacts of waste. The most recurrent system boundary was the cradle-to-grave, offering a comprehensive analysis as it covers all stages of biowaste treatment from collection to disposal. The studies highlight the environmental benefits of AD-based systems through energy production compensations, particularly in reducing global warming potential, compared with other treatment operations such as landfills. While replacing mineral fertilisers with digestate and compost is very well discussed, it raises concerns about heavy metal content and nutrient availability. Therefore, selective collection of organic waste is crucial to improve compost quality and AD efficiency, though it increases transportation costs.
Water hyacinth is an invasive species that causes eutrophication in lentic waters. While mechanical removal is effective, it generates hazardous waste with biological contamination risk. Composting is a safe waste treatment option, inhibiting seeds and yielding agriculturally suitable compost. Life cycle assessment evaluated the environmental impacts of six composting piles using eight different by-products (potato peel, cattle manure, wood chip, rice straw, potato leftovers, olive pomace and biochar), all formulations containing water hyacinth. The worst environmental performances were the M2 pile (water hyacinth + olive pomace + cattle manure + potato leftovers) which achieved the highest AP (47.33 kg SO2 eq.) and EP (10.56 kg PO4³− eq.), while M3 (water hyacinth + olive pomace + rice straw + potato leftovers) had the highest GWP (816.51 kg CO2 eq.) and OLD (2.99E-11 kg R11 eq.). The biological composting process contributed the most to the overall increase in the impact categories for all piles due to air emissions (CH4 and N2O). M3 and M5 (water hyacinth + wood chip) had the worst performance in fossil fuel consumption due to distances travelled from by-products and energy use in the maintenance of composting piles. Concerning packaging, Big Bags with polypropylene had a greater impact than polyethylene bags (50 kg capacity). Evaluating the potential avoidance of mineral fertilisers, M3 compost showed potential for reducing TSP fertiliser production by 46%. Overall, M4, which incorporated a mixture of water hyacinth, olive pomace, wood chips and biochar, was the most favourable option from an environmental point of view.
This study presents a process-based life cycle assessment (LCA) comparing conventional bagasse combustion with a biomass integrated gasification combined cycle (BIG-GT) system for bioelectricity generation in the Brazilian sugar-energy sector. A gate-to-gate framework was adopted to isolate the industrial energy conversion stage and enable a process-consistent comparison between configurations. The assessment integrates thermodynamic modeling with life cycle inventory and impact assessment, using aligned system boundaries, functional units, and inventory assumptions. The results indicate that both systems provide net environmental benefits, largely driven by electricity export and substitution effects. The gasification-based configuration consistently achieved improved environmental performance across all evaluated impact categories, with reductions of up to ~10% in photochemical ozone formation impacts and smaller improvements in climate change, particulate matter formation, and terrestrial acidification. These gains are primarily associated with higher electrical efficiency (23.4% versus 12.4%) and lower internal electricity demand, which increase net electricity export and associated environmental credits. However, the results also demonstrate that improvements in thermodynamic efficiency do not necessarily translate into proportional environmental gains. Rather than uniformly reducing impacts, the gasification-based configuration redistributes environmental burdens from core conversion stages to auxiliary operations such as biomass drying and gas cleaning, reflecting the greater structural complexity of advanced thermochemical systems. In addition, the gasification system exhibited lower sensitivity to operational variability, indicating greater robustness under the evaluated conditions. Overall, the findings demonstrate that the environmental advantages of gasification are strongly dependent on electricity substitution effects and system-level modeling assumptions, highlighting the importance of process-consistent methodological frameworks for avoiding structurally biased comparisons in LCA studies of bioenergy systems.