Crosswind action on a train poses a risk of vehicle overturning or derailment. To assess if new train designs fulfill the safety requirements, computational fluid dynamics is commonly used. This article presents a comprehensive wind flow analysis on an example of a TGV high-speed train. Large yaw angle range is studied with the application of widely used Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) turbulence models. The predictive performance of popular RANS-based models in that regime has not been reported extensively before. The context of simulations is a study of crosswind stability using methodology presented in norm EN 14067-6:2018. It is shown that for yaw angles up to 45 degrees, aerodynamic forces predicted by all the studied RANS-based models are consistent with experimental data. At larger yaw angles, flow structure becomes complicated, separation lines are no longer defined by geometry, and significant discrepancies between turbulence models appear, with relative differences between models up to 30%. A detailed study was performed to investigate differences between turbulence models for specific angles of 40, 60, and 80 degrees, which correspond to distinctive ranges of moment characteristics. Finally, a successful attempt was made to tune a GEKO turbulence model to fit the experimental data. This allowed us to reduce the maximum relative error in comparison to the experiment in the full yaw angles range down to 12.7%, which is in line with the norm requirements.
1 November 2019 in Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology
In time attack races, aerodynamics plays a vital role in achieving short track times. These races are characterized by frequent braking and acceleration supported by aerodynamic downforce. Usually, typical cars are modified for these races by amateurs. Adjusting the aerodynamic solutions to work with bodies developed for other flow conditions is difficult. This paper presents the results of a numerical analysis of the effects of installing a straight wing in front of or above the body on the modified vehicle system’s aerodynamic characteristics, particularly on the front wheels’ aerodynamic downforce values. The paper presents the methodology and results of calculations of the aerodynamic characteristics of a car with an additional wing placed in various positions in relation to the body. The numerical results are presented (Cd, Cl, Cm, Clf, Clr), as well as exemplary pressure distributions, pathlines, and visualizations of vortex structures. Strong interactions between the wing operation and body streamline structure are shown. An interesting and unexpected result of the analysis is that the possibility of obtaining aerodynamic downforce of the front wheels is identified, without an increase in aerodynamic drag, by means of a wing placed in a proper position in front of the body. A successful attempt to balance the additional downforce coming from the front wing on the front axle is made using a larger spoiler. However, for large angles of attack, periodically unsteady flow is captured with frequency oscillations of ca. 6–12 Hz at a car speed of 40 m/s, which may interfere with the sports car’s natural suspension frequency.
Generating aerodynamic downforce for the wheels on the front axle of a car is a much more difficult task than for the rear axle. This paper, submitted to the special issue of Energies “Future of Road Vehicle Aerodynamics”, presents an unusual solution to increase the aerodynamic downforce of the front axle for cars with covered wheels, with the use of an elastic splitter. The effect of the inflatable splitter on the aerodynamic forces and moments was studied in a DrivAer passenger car and a fast sports car, Arrinera Hussarya. Providing that the ground clearance was low enough, the proposed solution was successful in increasing the front axle downforce without a significant increase in drag force. The possibility of emergency application of such a splitter in the configuration of the body rotated by up to 2 degrees with the front end raised was also analyzed. An elastic, deformed splitter remained effective for the nonzero pitch case. The results of the calculations are presented in the form of numerical data of aerodynamic forces, pressure and velocity distributions, and their comparisons. The benefits of the elastic splitter are documented, and the noted disadvantages are discussed.
This paper, submitted to the special issue of Energies “Future of Road Vehicle Aerodynamics”, proposes and justifies the use of an old idea of generating downforce by actively drawing air from under the car body and exhausting it to the outside. Instead of traditional moving mechanical-curtain elements, a new method for sealing the clearance under the body with an air curtain is proposed. Basic information on the geometry and flow characteristics of such a solution suitable for use in automobiles is presented. The performance of such a fan-driven device generating downforce is studied over a wide range of driving speeds. The device allows for significantly improved vehicle acceleration, shorter braking distances, and extension of the range of safe cornering speeds. The paper shows the successive stages of development of the idea, from the 2D model to the 3D model, and an attempt to implement the device on a sports car. The distributions of pressure, velocity, pathlines and values of aerodynamic forces obtained at assumed fan compressions for different driving speeds are presented. The advantages and disadvantages of the analyzed device are discussed, and further optimization directions are outlined.