Oil sump lubrication is commonly used in gearboxes. When considering consistent speeds, oil immersion is usually set to low level in order to reduce associated power losses. This configuration is already used in some parts of helicopter mechanical transmissions, and it is under consideration as a lubrication solution for future electric powertrain where gearbox input speeds may be very high. The gear drag power losses are generally evaluated from either a churning power loss model for classic oil sump lubrication or a windage power loss model for oil jet lubrication. One may thus wonder how to estimate drag losses when considering a gear that only a small part is immersed. In this study, the authors investigate the transition between churning and windage phenomena for a spur gear. A series of torque measurements on a single spur gear rotating in an oil bath at numerous oil immersion levels have been carried out. Based on these results, a criterion to indicate which power loss model to use is proposed.
In high-speed rolling element bearings the drag forces can be prominent and it is demonstrated in this investigation that the classical models may not be appropriate for estimating correctly this power loss contribution. A modification of the models is thus proposed including the usual drag forces formulation relying upon drag coefficient to be evaluated from a numerical CFD approach. A three-dimensional approach that considers both the rings and the cylinders ends seems the only adequate approach to be used since a two-dimensional approach predicts a too low drag coefficient value. When using the former computed drag coefficient for the evaluation of the total power losses high values of oil volume fraction must be employed to recover the measured power losses.
This paper investigates the windage power losses generated by spur gears rotating in pure air by using a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code. The three-dimensional simulations are at first validated comparing CFD predictions with the power losses measured in similar conditions from other investigations. The volumetric flow rate which is expelled by the teeth is then analysed, and a correlation which is based on a classical approach used in turbomachinery is finally proposed which makes it possible to estimate windage losses for spur gears. It was observed that this latter approach seems satisfying since the formulation of the volumetric flow rate which is employed in the model is appropriate to each gear. Cette étude s’intéresse aux pertes par ventilation observées dans le cas d’engrenages droits et estimées à l’aide d’un code de calcul classique. L’approche numérique est d’une part validée par comparaison des prévisions numériques des pertes avec celles mesurées dans des conditions similaires. Les débits éjectés par la périphérie des roues dentées sont ensuite analysés, et un modèle capable d’estimer les pertes par ventilation et basé sur une analogie avec la cinématique de l’écoulement dans un système rotor est d’autre part proposé. Ce modèle semble adapté à l’estimation des pertes tant que le modèle du débit éjecté reste en rapport des roues dentées étudiées.
7 September 2015 in Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C: Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science
This paper investigates the windage power losses generated by helical gears rotating in pure air based on experimental results and a computational fluid dynamic code. It is found that the simulated flow patterns are totally different from those calculated for spur gears and that both tooth face width and helix angle are influential. The windage losses derived from Dawson’s and Townsend’s formulae are critically assessed using computational fluid dynamic results thus highlighting the limits of a unique formulation for accurate windage loss prediction. Finally, an analytical approach is suggested which gives good results providing that the flow rates at the boundaries of the inter-tooth domains can be estimated.
This paper introduces an experimental approach to study the distribution of power losses in an oil jet-lubricated planetary gear set, with the aim of increasing the efficiency of these gearboxes. A thermal model is developed to estimate power losses associated with temperature distribution. This model is applied to analyze experimental data collected from a dedicated test setup. Different configurations are studied to progressively validate the thermal network. In this paper, only a configuration composed of a rotating ring gear and a fixed planet carrier is studied. This configuration enables the validation of a thermal network developed from a basic configuration where power loss sources are not numerous. The study reveals that, for this configuration, load-independent power losses are primarily attributed to hydrodynamic losses in the bearings, while the gear windage effects are of second order. The power losses are then compared to those generated by the same planetary gear set but using a rotating planet carrier. The comparison shows that the configuration composed of the rotating ring gear and fixed planet carrier produces less power loss than the other configuration.