Objective : To develop a high-fidelity mathematical model intended to replicate the cardiovascular (CV) responses of a critically ill patient to vasoplegic shock-induced hypotension and vasopressor therapy. Methods: The mathematical model consists of a lumped-parameter CV physiology model with baroreflex modulation feedback and a phenomenological dynamic dose-response model of a vasopressor. The adequacy of the proposed mathematical model was investigated using an experimental dataset acquired from 10 pigs receiving phenylephrine (PHP) therapy after vasoplegic shock induced via sodium nitroprusside (SNP). Results: Upon calibration, the mathematical model could (i) faithfully replicate the effects of PHP on dynamic changes in blood pressure (BP), cardiac output (CO), and systemic vascular resistance (SVR) (root-mean-squared errors between measured and calibrated mathematical responses: mean arterial BP 2.5+/-1.0 mmHg, CO 0.2+/-0.1 lpm, SVR 2.4+/-1.5 mmHg/lpm; r value: mean arterial BP 0.96+/-0.01, CO 0.65+/-0.45, TPR 0.92+/-0.10) and (ii) predict physiologically plausible behaviors of unmeasured internal CV variables as well as secondary baroreflex modulation effects. Conclusion: This mathematical model is perhaps the first of its kind that can comprehensively replicate both primary (i.e., direct) and secondary (i.e., baroreflex modulation) effects of a vasopressor drug on an array of CV variables, rendering it ideally suited to pre-clinical virtual evaluation of the safety and efficacy of closed-loop control algorithms for autonomous vasopressor administration once it is extensively validated. Significance: This mathematical model architecture incorporating both direct and baroreflex modulation effects may generalize to serve as part of an effective platform for high-fidelity in silico simulation of CV responses to vasopressors during vasoplegic shock.
Burn patients require high-volume intravenous resuscitation with the goal of restoring global tissue perfusion to make up for burn-induced loss of fluid from the vasculature. Clinical standards of burn resuscitation are predominantly based on urinary output, which is not context-aware because it is not a trustworthy indicator of tissue perfusion. This paper investigates the initial development and analysis of a context-aware decision-support algorithm for burn resuscitation. In this context, we hypothesized that the use of a more context-aware surrogate of tissue perfusion may enhance the efficacy of burn resuscitation in normalizing cardiac output. Toward this goal, we exploited the arterial pulse wave analysis to discover novel surrogates of cardiac output. Then, we developed the cardiac output-enabled burn resuscitation decision-support (CaRD) algorithm. Using experimental data collected from animals undergoing burn injury and resuscitation, we conducted an initial evaluation and analysis of the CaRD algorithm in comparison with the commercially available Burn NavigatorTM algorithm. Combining a surrogate of cardiac output with urinary output in the CaRD algorithm has the potential to improve the efficacy of burn resuscitation. However, the improvement achieved in this work was only marginal, which is likely due to the suboptimal tuning of the CaRD algorithm with the limited available dataset. In this way, the results showed both promise and challenges that are crucial to future algorithm development.
20 September 2024 in Journal of Dynamic Systems, Measurement, and Control
This paper presents a virtual patient generator (VPG) intended to be used for preclinical in silico evaluation of autonomous vasopressor administration algorithms in the setting of experimentally induced vasoplegia. Our VPG consists of two main components: (i) a mathematical model that replicates physiological responses to experimental vasoplegia (induced by sodium nitroprusside (SNP)) and vasopressor resuscitation via phenylephrine (PHP) and (ii) a parameter vector sample generator in the form of a multidimensional probability density function (PDF) using which the parameters characterizing the mathematical model can be sampled. We developed and validated a mathematical model capable of predicting physiological responses to the administration of SNP and PHP. Then, we developed a parameter vector sample generator using a collective variational inference method. In a blind testing, the VPG developed by combining the two could generate a large number of realistic virtual patients (VPs), which could simulate physiological responses observed in all the experiments: on the average, 98.1% and 74.3% of the randomly generated VPs were physiologically legitimate and adequately replicated the test subjects, respectively, and 92.4% of the experimentally observed responses could be covered by the envelope formed by the subject-replicating VPs. In sum, the VPG developed in this paper may be useful for preclinical in silico evaluation of autonomous vasopressor administration algorithms.
Blood pressure (BP) management is a critical component of blood transfusion, but no mature technology capable of predicting BP response to blood transfusion exists. This paper concerns the development and preliminary in vivo testing of a BP prediction method applicable to hemorrhage and blood transfusion. Key obstacles are (i) large inter-individual variability in the BP response to blood transfusion, (ii) unknown hemorrhage, and (iii) input/state-dependent observability. To cope with these challenges, we developed a multi-modal sequential inference-enabled BP prediction method built upon a mathematical model of patient physiology parameterized by population-informed prior. The method infers patient-specific physiological state and hemorrhage, and uses them to predict future BP in a patient receiving blood transfusion. The in vivo testing of the method using the data collected from large animals undergoing hemorrhage and blood transfusion showed that it could adequately predict mean arterial BP with median absolute errors for 5-min and 15-min predictions of 3.1 mmHg and 7.4 mmHg as well as adequately infer physiological state and hemorrhage: all the hemorrhage events were detected with <3.5 min delay, with median F1 score of 85%. In sum, the prediction of BP response to blood transfusion may be feasible, even in the presence of unknown hemorrhage.
Introduction: Urine output (UOP) still remains the primary endpoint utilized as a surrogate for cardiac output (CO) and adequacy of perfusion during burn resuscitation. The role of arterial blood pressure (BP) waveform as a guiding tool for burn resuscitation has not been rigorously explored. As we move toward developing and validating novel endpoint to complement UOP, we compared the potential of pulse wave analysis (PWA) of arterial BP waveforms for estimating cardiac output (CO) and stroke volume (SV) in a large animal model of 40% total body surface area (TBSA) burns with varying resuscitation paradigms. Methods: Anesthetized swine were instrumented and hemorrhaged 15% of their blood volume, and sustained a 40% TBSA full-thickness contact burn with aluminum billets. Animals were kept in a surgical ICU setting overnight, during which anesthesia was maintained with a combination of propofol, ketamine, and fentanyl. Animals were randomized to 3 different intravenous fluid (lactated Ringer’s, LR) levels: under resuscitation with no IV fluids, adequate resuscitation protocolized with a clinical decision support tool, or over resuscitation with a starting rate of 500mL/hour. We computed 20 surrogate measures of CO and SV (10 each) via PWA of arterial BP, and calibrated them to reference CO via thermo-dilution and SV on a subject-by-subject basis. Surrogate performance was quantified in terms of correlation coefficient and root-mean-squared error (RMSE) relative to reference CO and SV. Results: Animals received 0±0, 4.4±1.6, and 9.1±1.3 mL/kg/% TBSA in the under, adequate, and over resuscitation groups (p=0.0036), respectively. Among the ten surrogate measures of CO and SV, 4 surrogates had positive proportionality to reference CO and SV consistently. The best surrogate measure of CO and SV was [mean BP-diastolic BP]/[heart period] and [mean BP-diastolic BP], respectively, which yielded r value of 0.82+/-0.19 and RMSE of 0.23+/-0.14 lpm for CO and r value of 0.85+/-0.17 and RMSE of 2.7+/-2.0 ml for SV (Fig. 1). Conclusions: The initial results suggest that PWA-based surrogates of CO and SV have the potential to track reference CO and SV in extremes of resuscitation post-burn. The current model produces under-resuscitated, adequately resuscitated, and over-resuscitated animals, making it possible to rigorously examine the efficacy of PWA-based tracking of CO and SV in a wide spectrum of burn resuscitation scenarios. Hence, PWA may provide metrics useful for developing surrogates of CO and SV as novel treatment endpoints of burn resuscitation that indicate perfusion and volume status of burn injury patients.