The cavitation erosion behavior of 316L stainless steel (SS 316L) fabricated by two additive manufacturing (AM) processes, namely laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) and laser directed energy deposition (L-DED), was investigated using the ASTM G32 vibratory apparatus in both the as-built (AB) and solution heat-treated (HT) conditions and compared with conventionally hot-rolled (CONV) material. Significant differences in microstructure, phase constitution, hardness, and defect morphology were observed among the processing routes, leading to distinct cavitation erosion responses. The L-PBF material exhibited a fully austenitic microstructure, with no detectable δ-ferrite, consistent with the extremely high cooling rates characteristic of this process, whereas the L-DED specimens retained a dual-phase microstructure containing austenite and δ-ferrite. Regardless of the heat-treatment condition, all AM-produced specimens demonstrated superior cavitation erosion resistance compared with the hot-rolled alloy. Heat treatment resulted in opposite trends in the mean cavitation response of the two AM routes, with an increase in the maximum erosion rate (MER) for L-PBF and a decrease for L-DED. The trend observed in L-PBF was associated with the dissolution of the cellular substructure and reduction in hardness, whereas that observed in L-DED was consistent with δ-ferrite dissolution, microstructural homogenization, and residual stress relief. Although the L-PBF specimens exhibited the highest hardness, they also showed a higher MER than the L-DED specimens, indicating that the ranking of cavitation resistance is not reproduced by hardness alone. To investigate the origin of this behavior, cross-sections perpendicular to the eroded surface were examined after 9 h of exposure. These observations suggest that mass loss involves subsurface crack nucleation, propagation, and linkage, and that the two routes differ substantially in the continuity and orientation of the available crack paths. In L-PBF, cracks were observed to extend laterally along regions associated with cell-colony and melt-pool boundaries, consistent with the isolation and detachment of comparatively large material volumes. In L-DED, the tortuous interdendritic δ-ferrite network and, after heat treatment, the more homogeneous matrix were associated with shorter and less laterally continuous crack paths, shallower damage, and considerably smaller detached fragments. These findings indicate that cavitation performance in additively manufactured 316L cannot be described by hardness alone and suggest an important role of microstructural stability, defect morphology, and subsurface crack-path continuity.