One of the essential components of various design methods for perpetual (or long-life) flexible pavements is elimination (or minimization) of bottom-up fatigue cracking. For this purpose, the concept of the fatigue endurance limit (FEL) is used. The FEL is defined as a strain threshold below which fatigue damage does not accumulate for any number of load repetitions. Different ranges of FEL values have been reported in the literature. Recent studies have showed that FEL is not a single value and depends on several factors. The NCHRP 9-44A project resulted in an FEL prediction model based on the micro-crack healing concept and stiffness, both of which can fluctuate throughout the service life of a pavement. In this study, NCHRP 9-44A FEL prediction model was implemented in the Mechanistic-Empirical Asphalt Pavement Analysis (MEAPA) web application to investigate the effect of fluctuating FEL on bottom-up fatigue cracking prediction in three typical road sections (low, medium, and high traffic) in Michigan. The critical bottom-up fatigue strains, predicted FEL, and predicted fatigue cracking for each road section have been compared. The results revealed that implementation of FEL is critical for accuracy in the prediction of fatigue cracking in relatively thick pavements that are subjected to high traffic loading. The effect of FEL, however, was minimal in thin pavements with low traffic levels. Therefore, given that the mechanistic-empirical pavement design methods are typically used while designing highly trafficked pavements (e.g., highways, arterials, etc.), proper implementation of the FEL concept in pavement design is very important.
5 September 2022 in International Journal of Pavement Engineering
Many road agencies worldwide still use the empirical AASHTO 1993 pavement design method. Since the release of the AASHTO 1993 design guide, many aspects of pavement design have changed, including asphalt material properties, traffic, environmental factors, etc. However, many agencies use a single layer coefficient for asphalt mixtures and pavements are currently designed with inaccurate values, as proved by many. This paper presents a four-step procedure (called AASHTO 93 Plus method) to determine structural layer coefficients of asphalt mixtures. The AASHTO 93 Plus method considers viscoelasticity and temperature-dependency of asphalt mixtures to estimate the layer coefficient. Five-hundred-eighteen (518) flexible pavements from USA and Canada roads and 1599 HMAs from the Long-Term Pavement Performance (LTPP) database were analyzed. The results showed that the new material-specific layer coefficients were well above the typical value of 0.44. The total number of 3,726 IRI data records of these 518 pavements were converted to PSI and then compared to those obtained from the traditional AASHTO 93 and AASHTO 93 Plus methods for validation. Results confirmed that the conventional AASHTO 93 method predicts faster deterioration of pavement conditions over time, while the results of AASHTO 93 Plus method better aligned with the field data.
7 October 2025 in Construction and Building Materials
This paper reports the details of a computationally efficient finite element analysis code (called MatFEA), designed specifically for flexible pavements, where stress-dependent characteristics of unbound layers are considered. The stress-dependent nonlinearity of the unbound materials has been modeled in MatFEA through an iterative approach. MatFEA was mainly developed to improve the Mechanistic-Empirical Asphalt Pavement Analysis (MEAPA) web application with capability of analysis/design of nonlinear pavement structures. A specific-purpose mesh generation algorithm was developed for the MatFEA in which the mesh density was dynamically adjustable based on the expected stress magnitude. To verify the results of the MatFEA, 12,000 nonlinear pavement structures with different structural and loading properties were generated and analyzed with MatFEA. The same pavement structures were modeled in a general-purpose FE-based ABAQUS™ program. The results of this study showed that the critical pavement structural responses from the MatFEA were almost identical with those modeled by ABAQUS™ program. The average runtime of MatFEA for analyzing each pavement structure was about 1.13 s. Finally, it was concluded that application of the dynamically adjustable mesh generation algorithm in the MatFEA helped achieve a reasonably high accuracy as well as efficient runtime, which brings the advantage of implementing the MatFEA as a pavement structural response model in the mechanistic-empirical pavement analysis/design procedures.
The resilient modulus (MR) and the backcalculated modulus from the FWD testing (EFWD) of the unbound layers are critical inputs in the analysis/design of pavements. Several studies have tried to develop a conversion factor between these two parameters, while the nonlinear stress dependency of unbound materials and the pavement strain response are mostly missing from the literature. This study aims to compare the laboratory-measured MR of recycled aggregate base (RAB) materials and a virgin aggregate base using field-based EFWD and tries to establish pavement’s responses to loading using vertical strains from both the MR and EFWD values of the respective materials as comparability parameters between the two. For this purpose, a control virgin aggregate (VA, limestone) and three types of RAB materials were selected to construct four test sections. The test sections were modeled in layered elastic- and finite-element-based pavement response models to calculate the vertical strains at the mid-depth of the base and top of the subgrade layers. A comparison of the lab-calculated vertical strains using MR with actual vertical strains in the field from EFWD showed that there was no relationship between the two stiffness parameters in all tested RABs. The vertical strains, based on the lab MR, undermined the stiffness of the recycled aggregates in the field. In contrast, the values of EFWD based on the vertical strains remained close to the MR strains of limestone (VA) throughout the testing period, establishing an EFWD vs. MR relationship (MR = 0.87 EFWD). The results also show that fine RCA was a better-performing material over three years. This research not only explores how the hydration process in RABs limits the development of MR-EFWD correlations but also underscores the need to consider real-world conditions when assessing their performance.
17 February 2026 in Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Ground Improvement
This study investigates the long-term performance of recycled and virgin aggregate base materials in flexible pavements by comparing linear and non-linear pavement structural response models. The materials included coarse and fine recycled concrete aggregate (RCA), limestone (control), and blends of reclaimed asphalt pavement with RCA. Pavement distresses, such as fatigue cracking (both top-down and bottom-up) and rutting, were predicted using the mechanistic-empirical pavement design guide methodology, where the critical structural responses were obtained using linear elastic analysis (LEA) and finite element analysis (FEA) approaches. Data from falling weight deflectometer (FWD) tests and laboratory resilient modulus (MR) tests were also used separately, in both approaches, to study the differences between in situ and laboratory conditions. The results showed that RCAs exhibited higher stiffness and improved performance compared to limestone. LEA-based analysis produced conservative performance predictions, while non-linear FEA-based analysis offered lower distresses. Also, FWD responses suggested stiffer in situ conditions for RCA base layers, in case of both models, when compared to laboratory MR results.