Fires pose significant risks, encompassing loss of life, destruction of property, and substantial adverse impacts on the economy. Therefore, the prioritization of fire safety in building structures must be embraced by all relevant stakeholders, including building owners, authorities, and the general public. However, traditional fire safety assessment methods can be laborious and challenging, impeding the identification of potential fire hazards and the selection of optimal fire safety measures. To this end, this research study offers an analytic hierarchy process for assessing building fire safety. Two case studies are presented to support this model’s outperformance compared with conventional assessment techniques. The proposed method yields hazard ratings of 5.3 and 4.3 along with safety ratings of 5.5 and 5.9 for the two case studies. Additionally, the proposed model yields comprehensible, well-documented, and comparable results. Therefore, it serves as a valuable decision-making tool for evaluating fire hazards and enhancing the efficiency of building structures. As a result, decision-makers can identify current and future fire protection and prevention requirements with greater ease and precision, making the decision-making process more effective.
1 October 2021 in Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
The monitoring and determination of the suitable time for performing the maintenance works of municipal infrastructures consisting of water, sewer, drainage, and road networks have been matters of concern for the related authorities. Infrastructure facilities usually share the same space, which dictates the importance of implementing integrated maintenance, rehabilitation, and replacement (MR&R) plans. The optimization of MR&R plans for all these facilities greatly depends on knowing how to predict the future status of these facilities and how much cost would be incurred by such activities. This research deals with the development of a financial model based on an integrated MR&R approach by utilizing geographical information system (GIS)-based data and tools. Such systems maintain the data of each facility on GIS platforms and reflect its operational status regarding need and priority for rehabilitation. Two case studies are performed for the research along with numerical examples using the developed financial model for integrated MR&R. Various factors including sacrificed service life cost, direct cost, and social and environmental impact costs are incorporated in the model. The results show that there is a significant difference in costs incurred when using the integrated MR&R activity approach for replacing sewer pipes along with water supply pipes compared with dealing with each facility separately because it reduced the cost of sewer replacement by almost 39% and 37% for first and second case, respectively. The reduction is further expected to increase in case more facilities are rehabilitated at the same time. The application and the validation of the developed model are done by using a logical approach of applicability factor. The research shall prove to be beneficial for the infrastructure design and execution industries as well as the related municipal authorities in the management and planning of cost and execution works efficiently.
The quality performance of contractors in sustainable construction projects is a major concern for the industry. Over the past decade, studies on measurements, factors, and indicators for assessment of the professional conduct of construction companies are to be found in the sustainable construction management literature. There is adequate evidence over the last decade that an increasing number of construction professionals have adopted the measurement of the professional conduct of contractors as a tool to support their future decisions. The method of the Analytical Hierarchy (AHP) process has been deployed to identify the major factors and sub-factors involved in sustainable construction in Saudi Arabia. Using several governing factors, including quality of document submittals (QDS), quality system implementation (QSI), and quality of construction works (QCW), a working framework was developed by using the pair-wise comparison method. The results show that proper accountability and keen consideration of factors that could hinder sustainable construction by contractors contribute to the development of a better perspective on quality issues. After a critical analysis, a Performance Quality Index was developed, and a benchmark value was obtained. The benchmark value of PQI will assist project managers and owners in the sustainable construction sector as a reference for future improvement in the quality performance of contractors.
Construction projects in Saudi Arabia are frequently plagued by cost overruns and time delays, with change orders being a major contributing factor. These modifications, which can occur at various stages throughout the project lifecycle, tend to negatively impact costs and cash flows. This study developed a classification impact index model to assess the potential impact of change orders on contractors’ cash flow in building construction projects. This study identified the factors and subfactors affecting contractors’ cash flow, organizing them into a hierarchical structure of main and sub-main factors. The relative importance of these factors was then assessed using the Analytical Hierarchical Process (AHP). The findings showed that project financing schemes had the most substantial impact (44%), followed by contract type (30%) and characteristics of change orders (26%). Among the subfactors, cash availability under project financing had the highest influence at 56%, while the value of change orders was the most significant subfactor under change order characteristics, contributing 30%. The Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT) was subsequently used to evaluate the attributes of these factors, applying utility scores to provide a more comprehensive assessment. The resulting Change Order Impact Index integrates AHP and MAUT to quantify the impacts of change orders. This model categorizes the effects of change orders into four levels: minor, moderate, significant, and severe. The developed Change Order Impact Index provides a systematic approach for proactively managing financial risks, optimizing project financing decisions, and supporting contractors in mitigating the impacts of change orders to maintain financial stability and reduce negative impacts on their cash flow.
Change orders in construction projects frequently lead to disputes, schedule delays, and cost overruns, particularly in the rapidly expanding construction sector of Saudi Arabia. Traditional techniques for resolving claims like litigation and arbitration are predominantly reactive in nature and do not facilitate proactive assessments of the impact of change orders before disputes materialize. A BIM-based framework is developed in this study to assess change orders in terms of time and cost with visualization functions through an integration of Autodesk Revit, Primavera and Navisworks, combined in a 5D virtual environment. The framework utilizes 3D modelling, scheduling and cost management (3D/4D/5D) supported by virtual reality (VR) visualization to create an interactive decision support platform for the project stakeholders. A real residential building case study was utilized to validate the framework, and a design modification was developed and analyzed using the BIM environment. The project cost has increased as a result of change order from SAR 411,437.26 to SAR 428,280.16, which is 4.1% of the total project cost. Also, there are deviations in the schedule which occurred from Month 4. The study results show that the suggested integrated BIM-based framework assesses the impact of change order, physically and visually, on the project time and cost that was required by the industry. The study is innovative in bringing together BIM layout, scheduling, and cost management with VR-supported visualization in a single decision support environment, allowing stakeholders to take into account the implications of change orders before they become real claims and disputes. The proposed framework allows transparent communication, collective decision making with stakeholders and early impact assessment, in contrast to existing approaches whose focus is primarily on claim resolution or improving coordination. This will improve project performance and how change orders are managed.