Recently, heritage education has undergone significant development, consolidating itself as a scientific discipline in the last two decades. In this sense, it is a key element for teaching history and training social and civic skills. However, in Spanish school contexts the presence of heritage in connection with historical education is currently scarce and anecdotal. Transforming this situation necessarily involves knowing the opinion of future Secondary Education teachers about the possibilities that they grant to heritage to develop historical thinking. Only in this way it is possible to detect the needs that future teachers show to intervene in them and improve training processes at the university. Therefore, this paper analyses the perceptions of heritage in future secondary education teachers at three Spanish universities (Malaga, Almeria, and Murcia), with a total sample of 112 participants (n = 112). It combines a quantitative study using a Likert scale questionnaire, with a qualitative one, by means of a series of open questions about the participants’ perceptions of teaching methodologies and didactic resources. This allows some striking conclusions to be drawn, as well as certain contradictions that allude to the gap between the hegemonic forms of teaching that they have known as students, and those that they would like to develop when they enter teaching. These trainee teachers attach great importance to the use of tangible and intangible heritage to teach history and make it an attractive subject. They also show great interest in local history, museums, and new technologies. All of this is rarely used in the teaching of history in Spain at the Secondary Education stage, and therefore is a deficiency that future teachers recognize needs addressing. The teaching of heritage should promote a greater role for students, making them builders of their own learning. This means acquiring not only concepts, but above all skills and civic values, based on the study of heritage.
Los cambios que han acontecido en nuestra sociedad requieren de nuevas estrategias de enseñanza y de nuevas finalidades que construyan una ciudadanía con espíritu crítico y conciencia de pertenencia a un mundo amplio y multicultural. El objetivo principal de esta investigación es analizar los recuerdos del profesorado de Educación Secundaria en formación sobre la metodología didáctica utilizada en las clases de Historia, y sus opiniones sobre las estrategias más adecuadas para enseñar esta materia. La investigación se ha realizado en la especialidad de Geografía e Historia del Máster de Formación del Profesorado. Se seleccionaron cuatro grupos en las universidades de Murcia, Málaga, Castilla-La Mancha y Almería en el curso académico 2018/2019, recogiendo una muestra de 129 participantes (n=129). Los resultados muestran que no existen grandes diferencias entre universidades tanto en recuerdos como en intenciones sobre la metodología didáctica que creen que deben utilizar en la clase de Historia. Sin embargo, sí hay diferencias significativas de género: las mujeres tienen unos recuerdos más tradicionales de las clases de Historia, y están más a favor del uso de recursos digitales.Palabras clave: Formación del profesorado; Educación histórica; Metodología didáctica; Recursos digitales; Competencia digital
Desde hace décadas, diversas investigaciones han puesto de manifiesto el amplio potencial didáctico y educativo que poseen los temas controvertidos para la formación del pensamiento social y crítico en el alumnado. Sin embargo, en la actualidad, su presencia en las aulas sigue siendo escasa. En esta investigación, indagamos en las concepciones y prácticas docentes de veinte maestros y maestras de Educación Primaria, procedentes de distintos centros, con el objetivo de conocer la formación inicial y continua que han recibido para trabajar estos contenidos, cómo valoran su tratamiento para la enseñanza de las Ciencias Sociales y el uso real que hacen de los mismos. Para ello, hemos empleado un cuestionario con preguntas abiertas y cerradas que profundizan en estos aspectos. Tras el análisis cuantitativo de la información, los resultados revelan una escasa o nula formación que genera inseguridad; la valoración positiva de estas problemáticas como elementos que favorecen la motivación del alumnado y la adquisición de competencias; y un uso reducido que se justifica por la falta de formación y la controversia que comportan. Como conclusión, destacamos la necesidad de mejorar la formación inicial y continua del profesorado, a partir de propuestas que incluyan el trabajo con problemáticas sociales y favorezcan su inclusión en los contextos educativos.
In this article the evolution of research on Historical Thinking is analyzed based on national and international dissertations defended in the last twenty-five years. For this, we have followed a systematic search process in the main databases worldwide, which has reported a total of 163 dissertations. These works have been analyzed from a descriptive quantitative methodological approach, with the SPSS statistical analysis program and the Voyant Tools tool. The results offer us information about the number of researches carried out, their evolution over time, the countries, languages and universities with the highest production, and the main topics studied. We conclude that, despite the increase in doctoral thesis on Historical Thinking in recent years, there are still research gaps that have hardly been studied.
At present, there is a great deal of research demonstrating the educational potential of heritage for the teaching of history. However, relevant studies have shown that, although it is a resource which is widely valued by teachers, its incorporation into the classroom remains limited. The aim of this study is to analyze the opinions of teachers in initial training regarding the use of heritage in the classrooms and to inquire about their relationship with their own teaching approaches, given that these may influence the use or evaluation they make of this resource. This study, which is non-experimental and quantitative in nature, has employed as a research tool a questionnaire with the participation of 646 students of the master’s degrees in Teacher Training in Geography and History of 22 different universities, representing 70% of the universities that offer this degree in Spain. The most significant results show a broad interest in heritage among future secondary education and baccalaureate level teachers, although there is a preference for heritage resources more linked to their undergraduate studies (History, History of Art, Archeology) compared with heritage resources of a technological nature. Regarding teaching approaches, it has been observed that those who present a student-based approach (CCSF) value heritage more highly. Given these results, we consider it necessary to improve the initial training of teachers regarding existing heritage resources and to adapt teaching approaches in order to achieve a greater integration of heritage in history education.
26 September 2018 in REIDICS. Revista de Investigación en Didáctica de las Ciencias
This paper presents a project, conceived as action research, which has been implemented within the framework of teacher training, specifically, in the second year of the Degree in Primary Education of the University of Almeria. The main objective is to develop professional competences in future teachers, who provide them with the necessary strategies to train “global” citizens, capable of understanding their world and engage with it. The project has focused on a relevant social problem such as the situation of Syrian refugee children, a subject that, unfortunately, is very topical in our days. The objectives that we set out have their origin in the model of teacher we want to train. Related to this, we asked ourselves if competences offered by the framework of the European Higher Education Area are sufficient to turn our university students into professionals with critical, social, ethical and democratic thinking through working with relevant social problems. It was important to develop a critical training model with the intention that students will realize the need to transform Social Sciences into an instrument that makes possible, from the school, the social change. We also wanted to overcome prejudices in the students about the possibilities that offer the curriculum design to work on these topics, and show them that curricular contents should be put at the service of education to transform citizenship and commit to action. In this paper we advance the theoretical foundation on which the project is based, as well as the phases in which it has been organized for its development. Although we are in an initial phase of analysis of results, we can establish some first conclusions that reveal the positive impact of the project.