Conventional applications of the Galvanostatic Intermittent Titration Technique (GITT) and EIS for estimating chemical diffusivity in battery electrodes face issues such as insufficient relaxation time to reach equilibrium, excessively long pulse durations that violate the short-time diffusion assumption, and the assumption of sequential electrode reaction and diffusion processes. In this work, a quasi-equilibrium criterion of 0.1 mV h−1 was applied to NMC622 electrodes, yielding 8–9 h relaxations below 3.8 V, but above 3.8 V, voltage decayed linearly and indefinitely, even upon discharging titration, showing unusual nonmonotonic relaxation behavior. The initial 36-s transients of a 10-min galvanostatic pulse and diffusion impedance in series with the electrode reaction yielded consistent diffusivity values. However, solid-state diffusion in spherical active particles within porous electrodes, where ambipolar diffusion occurs in the pore electrolyte with , requires a physics-based three-rail transmission line model (TLM). The corrected diffusivity may be three to four times higher. An analytic two-rail TLM approximating the three-rail numerical model was applied to temperature- and frequency-dependent EIS data. This approach mitigates parameter ambiguity and unphysical correlations in EIS. Physics-based EIS enables the identification of multistep energetics and the diagnosis of performance and degradation mechanisms.
The galvanostatic intermittent titration technique (GITT) was applied to NMC622 positive electrodes, with Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) performed at quasi-equilibrium conditions determined by cutoff criteria based on relaxation rates. Below an open-circuit voltage (OCV) of 3.8 V, the cutoff criterion of 0.1 mV h−1 was reached after approximately 8 hours. However, above 3.8 V, a non-saturating voltage decay was observed, increasing up to ∼0.56 mV h−1 above 4.1 V during charging steps. This persistent voltage decay upon subsequent discharging steps led to non-monotonic relaxation behavior. A pulse time of 10 minutes did not satisfy the t dependence required for GITT kinetic analysis. Instead, the initial 36-second transients were extended for chemical diffusivity evaluation, aligning with the Warburg-like response observed in EIS, consistent with the sequential reaction-diffusion assumption. GITT analysis for solid-state diffusivity is ineffective for spherical active particles dispersed in porous electrodes and performs even worse due to liquid-phase diffusion within the pores, where t+=0.3. The apparent SOC-independent chemical diffusivity obtained from GITT across both low and high OCV ranges suggests that the process is dominated by liquid-phase diffusion. The application of the physics-based three-rail transmission line model (TLM) developed by Gaberšček et al. in EIS holds practical potential for deconvoluting the two diffusion kinetics.