High-performance fiber-reinforced concrete (HPFRC) offers exceptional strength, ductility, and durability, making it highly promising for electric power pipe jacking applications. However, limited research exists on the mechanical properties of HPFRC pipes, especially regarding reinforcement schemes. This study bridges this gap by using a combination of three-point testing, analytical calculations, and numerical simulations to investigate the mechanical behavior and performance of HPFRC pipes under various reinforcement configurations. The results show that the load–displacement curve of HPFRC pipes initially follows a linear elastic relationship, but as the load exceeds 200 kN/m, displacement increases and cracks form, with failure occurring at 410 kN/m. HPFRC pipes demonstrate significantly enhanced load-bearing and crack resistance capabilities, with reduced reinforcement and wall thickness compared to traditional materials, maintaining high load-bearing capacity even after damage. The three analysis methods generally align in terms of load-bearing and failure processes, though the analytical method reveals limitations in accurately predicting crack widths. The study also reveals that reinforcement schemes significantly affect the pipes’ structural performance, with double layer and inner layer reinforcement providing superior damage resistance. This study contributes new insights into HPFRC pipe performance and provides a basis for optimizing reinforcement designs in pipe jacking projects.