The current pandemic of the SARS-CoV-2 virus requires measures to reduce the risk of infection. In addition to the usual hygiene measures, air cleaners are a recommended solution to decrease the viral load in rooms. Suitable technologies range from pure filters to inactivating units, such as cold plasma or UVC irradiation. Such inactivating air cleaners, partly combined with filter technology, are available on the market in various designs, dimensions and technical specifications. Since it is not always clear whether they may produce undesirable by-products, and the suitability for particular applications cannot be assessed on the basis of the principle of operation, the effectivity of six inactivating devices was investigated in a near-real environment. The investigations were based on a standard method published by the VDI. The procedure was extended in such a way that a permanent virus source was simulated, which corresponds to the presence of a person suffering from COVID-19 in a room. The study addresses the difference of the mere presence of viruses to the determination of the virulence. As a result, a deep understanding is provided between the behavior of a virus as a pure aerosolized particle and its real infectivity in order to enable the assessment of suitable air cleaners.
In a flight test facility twin-aisle cabin demonstrator, a test series was conducted with the objective to investigate cleaning methods for recirculated air. Based on the data, a 3D zonal airflow simulation model of particle spread and cleaning performance was validated with the aim of extrapolating results to arbitrary aircraft cabins. For the tests, particles containing a phi6 bacteriophage, a virus only attacking a specific bacterium and with a similar structure to SARS-CoV-2, was dosed through a breathing head. The particle distribution and infectiveness of the air samples were measured. State-of-the-art HEPA filtering and cleaners based on UV-C and plasma were integrated in the recirculated air path and experimentally investigated. The test results showed the best cleaning performance for the state-of-the-art HEPA filter, while the alternatives showed lower performance levels. It was noted that infectiveness and particle count did not necessarily follow a monotonic function, making the link between these two quantities challenging. Therefore, modeling showed to be able to properly replicate particle distribution in the cabin, while an assumption of infectiveness depending on particle count had to be made. The model could successfully be applied to a single-aisle aircraft cabin geometry.
Ultraviolet (UV) radiation can be used to inactivate microorganisms, with upper-room UV germicidal irradiation (UR-UVGI) representing a promising approach. This study investigated the inactivation of the airborne surrogate virus Phi6 by a UR-UVGI system based on light-emitting diodes (LEDs) in a realistic test setup. Two test scenarios were used, one with continuous Phi6 release, simulating a source located in the room and leading to a dynamic equilibrium, and the second simulating a situation in which the source has left the room and an exponential decay is evaluated. The “Incremental Evaluation Model” was adapted and used to evaluate the dynamic equilibrium measurement. At a position in the breathing direction 5 m away from the Phi6 source, the loss coefficient (air exchange rate) was 25 h−1 in the first scenario and 30 h−1 in the second. These results show that UR-UVGI systems can effectively inactivate microorganisms. However, at 1 m distance from the Phi6 source perpendicular to the breathing direction, only minimal inactivation was observed due to short-circuit airflow. At this position, the loss coefficient was <2 h−1 in the first scenario and 17 h−1 in the second scenario, indicating that short-circuit airflows can only be detected by dynamic equilibrium measurements.
This paper describes an experimental investigation on the spread of a virus in a business jet cabin and the potential of ionization to reduce the pathogen load. In contrast to priorly investigated recirculation air cleaning, ionization can act directly in the cabin by introducing ions into the supply air. Tests were performed by emitting a surrogate virus through a breathing head in a business jet mock-up. The results allow for the conclusion that ionization technology, along with increased airflow, is a well-suited tool to sanitize cabins. Additionally, the effect of ionization on particles was investigated where it became obvious that the presence of particles reduces the ion level; however, the presence of ions hardly impact particles.