Background: The increasing adoption of digital workflows in implant dentistry necessitates rigorous assessment of intraoral scanning, particularly for complex full-arch rehabilitations like All-on-Four prostheses, where posterior implant angulation may impact the accuracy of optical data acquisition. Objectives: This in vitro study aimed to assess the accuracy of digital intraoral scanners in scanning All-on-Four implant models with different posterior implant angulations. Methods: Two epoxy resin All-on-Four implant models were fabricated with two posterior implant angulations (30-degree and 45-degree). Both models were digitized to obtain control datasets using a Smart Optics reference scanner (REF). Four intraoral scanners were comparatively assessed: Cerec Omnicam AC (OMN), Trios 4 (TRI), Cerec Primescan AC (PRI), and Medit i700 (MED), with nine scans per each scanner (n = 9). All STL files were exported and analyzed using Geomagic Control X with root mean square (RMS) values computed for trueness and precision assessments. Results: The comparison between IOS types in terms of trueness revealed that with 30° angulation, the MED group showed the statistically significant least deviation (p = 402). With 45° angulation, both PRI and OMN scanners showed the statistically significant highest deviation values (p = 0.047 and 0.007, respectively). MED again showed the statistically significant least deviation (p = 402). For precision evaluation in 30° angulation models, PRI and OMN scanners showed the statistically significant least deviation values (p = 402 and <0.001, respectively). While, in 45° angulation models, no statistically significant inter-scanner differences were observed. Conclusions: While MED, PRI, and OMN scanners demonstrated clinical validity for 30° angled posterior implants, only the MED system achieved sufficient accuracy for 45° tilt. These findings emphasize the critical relationship between scanner selection and extreme implant angulations in full-arch digital workflows.
Objectives: To assess the impact of PVS impression material viscosity and implant angulation on the three-dimensional accuracy of implant casts in a partially edentulous situation using the closed-tray technique. Materials and Methods: Three epoxy resin mandibular partially edentulous models (Kennedy Class I) were fabricated, each with four implant analogues placed at teeth positions 35, 37, 45, and 47. The anterior analogues were positioned parallel (0), while the posterior analogues were placed at different angulations: Group 1, 30° mesiodistal; Group 2, 20° mesiodistal; Group 3, 20° buccolingual. All analogues were placed 2 mm subgingivally. Closed-tray impressions (n = 8 per subgroup) were made using either heavy + light body PVS or monophase PVS. Resulting stone casts were scanned, and STL files were processed and analyzed using reverse engineering software (Geomagic Control X). Three-dimensional deviations (root mean square, RMS) between reference and test models were calculated by superimposition and best-fit algorithm. Results: With monophase PVS, implant angulation significantly influenced cast accuracy (p < 0.001). The 30° MD group exhibited the highest deviation (96 ± 7 µm), followed by the 20° BL group (81 ± 6 µm), then the 20° MD group (75 ± 6 µm). In contrast, no statistically significant difference in accuracy was observed among angulation groups when using heavy + light body PVS (77 ± 3 µm, 82 ± 13 µm, and 79 ± 8 µm for 30° MD, 20° BL, and 20° MD, respectively; p = 0.550). Conclusions: Both monophase and heavy + light body PVS impression materials produced clinically acceptable accuracy for closed-tray implant impressions. However, the heavy + light body PVS demonstrated greater consistency across various implant angulations and is recommended for multiple angulated subgingival posterior implants when using the closed-tray technique.
About Me
Lecturer of Crowns and Bridges at the faculty of dental medicine for girls-Al Azhar University
Lecturer of Crowns and Bridges at the faculty of dental medicine for girls-Al Azhar University