Systems presenting haptic information have emerged as an important technological advance in assisting individuals with sensory impairments or amputations, where the aim is to enhance sensory perception or provide sensory substitution through tactile feedback. These systems provide information on limb positioning, environmental interactions, and gait events, significantly improving mobility in amputees and their confidence about using such devices. This review summarizes recent progress in haptic feedback systems by providing a comparative analysis of different feedback approaches, evaluating their clinical effectiveness and usability, tactile feedback system design, and user experience, while identifying key gaps in the literature. These insights can contribute to the advancement of more effective, user-centered haptic feedback systems tailored for lower limb prosthetics. The findings are aimed at guiding future research in designing adaptive, intuitive, and clinically viable feedback mechanisms, fostering the widespread implementation of haptic systems in both assistive and rehabilitative applications.
The lack of reliable sensory input from prosthetic limbs limits transfemoral amputees’ ability to perceive limb movement without visual monitoring. This study evaluated design parameters of a proposed forearm-based vibrotactile system in a pre-clinical, design-level perceptual evaluation, conveying prosthetic joint positions through patterned vibrations to provide non-invasive proprioceptive feedback. Healthy participants completed two experiments assessing detection of tactile cues from dual-actuator bands on the wrist and elbow representing assumed ankle and knee positions. The effects of temporal structuring (sequential vs. simultaneous stimulation), actuator configuration, amplitude and frequency settings, and signal duration on response accuracy were examined. Sequential vibrations produced significantly higher recognition accuracy than simultaneous presentation (72.4% vs. 42.7%, p < 0.001) in a variety of vibration signal parameter values. Actuator placement also influenced performance: simultaneous stimulation on opposite forearm sides yielded significantly lower accuracy (p < 0.001) than same-side configurations, whereas this directional effect was not significant for sequential presentation. Accuracy did not differ significantly between equal and unequal amplitude or frequency levels across actuators. Longer stimulus durations improved accuracy, increasing from 82.3% at 60 ms to 92.5% at 240 ms, though the results indicated a saturation point, suggesting an optimal temporal window. These findings inform the design of forearm-based sensory feedback systems for improved prosthetic limb control.
Providing reliable sensory feedback is one of the most challenging aspects of transfemoral prosthetics, motivating the development of intuitive vibrotactile interfaces capable of conveying information about limb position in real-time. The aim of this study was to develop a vibrotactile feedback prototype and examine which interstimulus intervals (ISIs) and vibration waveforms might best enhance recognition of sequential tactile patterns. The results will be used to inform the development of a prototype to be tested on participants with transfemoral amputation where prosthetic feedback is provided. A forearm-mounted six-actuator feedback system, encoding eight lower-limb configurations, was used in two experiments with healthy adults. Experiment 1 assessed recognition accuracy across ISIs from 10 to 110 ms, while Experiment 2 compared sinusoidal and square waveforms under matched conditions. Recognition accuracy was high across all tested conditions, with no significant effects of ISI (p = 0.79) or waveform type (p = 0.17). These results indicate that participants were able to interpret spatially distributed vibrotactile patterns even under rapid temporal sequencing and with differing signal shapes. The system therefore offers design flexibility for real-time prosthetic feedback, suggesting that fast update rates may be achievable without a statistically detectable reduction in perceptual clarity within the tested conditions. These findings provide practical guidance for developing robust, user-friendly sensory substitution systems intended to increase proprioceptive awareness in transfemoral prosthesis users.