Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR), a comparatively new technology in the field of underwater surveying, has principally been used for taking precise measurement of undersea structures in the oil and gas industry. Typically, the LiDAR is deployed on a remotely operated vehicle (ROV), which will “land” on the seafloor in order to generate a 3D point cloud of its environment from a stationary position. To explore the potential of subsea LiDAR on a moving platform in an environmental context, we deployed an underwater LiDAR system simultaneously with a multibeam echosounder (MBES), surveying Kingston Reef off the coast of Rottnest Island, Western Australia. This paper compares and summarises the relative accuracy and characteristics of underwater LiDAR and multibeam sonar and investigates synergies between sonar and LiDAR technology for the purpose of benthic habitat mapping and underwater simultaneous localisation and mapping (SLAM) for Autonomous Underwater Vehicles (AUVs). We found that LiDAR reflectivity and multibeam backscatter are complementary technologies for habitat mapping, which can combine to discriminate between habitats that could not be mapped with either one alone. For robot navigation, SLAM can be effectively applied with either technology, however, when a Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) is available, SLAM does not significantly improve the self-consistency of multibeam data, but it does for LiDAR.
Modern multibeam echosounders collect bathymetric soundings, seafloor backscatter intensities, and water column backscatter values. The water column data can be used to identify features or biology above the seafloor with a broad range of applications. A key limitation for the analysis of this data is the presence of intrinsic system artifact patterns due to transducer design and receiver-array sidelobe-induced signal interferences. In this article, a method is described for simulating and removing these artifacts based on a “reference ping,” created using a subset of clear water data, which captures intrinsic artifacts present in the original data set. This reference ping, after adjusting for the range and seafloor amplitude values of each ping, is used to simulate ping-specific artifact patterns (“simulated ping”), which can be removed from the original data for improving target identification within the water column. This method was applied to five different Kongsberg Discovery multibeam echosounder systems covering a range of operational characteristics. Comparison of simulated pings with clear water data acquired by all systems shows greater than 0.9 R2 correlation, highlighting the efficacy of the method to reproduce intrinsic system artifacts prevalent in commonly used multibeam echosounders. The root-mean-squared error between simulated pings and original data was used to demonstrate the method's effectiveness in removing artifacts, with values of <0.04 for all systems. Large values were also used to identify potential features of interest within the water column. This method provides a promising foundation for improved water column analysis, either as a stand-alone method or combined with other current processing methods.