Neema Trivedi-Bateman

Dr. Neema Trivedi-Bateman

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

8Years (2019-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
4 August 2021 in Psychology, Crime & Law
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
NTNeema Trivedi-Bateman
Neema Trivedi-Bateman
ECEmma L. Crook
Emma L. Crook
In recent decades, the relationship between weak empathy and the development of antisocial and offending behaviours has been well established. In the first review of its kind, this paper outlines the current implementation of empathy intervention programmes in a variety of disciplines. This paper will identify some key agents that are instrumental in empathy development and build a case to suggest that where such traditional sources of empathy development are inadequate, interventions are crucial to bridge the gap. To date, the few offender empathy interventions that have been implemented and assessed heed mixed results by crime type, sample type, gender, and empathy type. Novel, evidence-led recommendations will be made in relation to the timing, content, format, length, and location of future interventions, and the importance of the consideration of baseline empathy and individual differences will be outlined. Deficient empathy must be of central concern to criminal justice agencies and identified and addressed from infancy and throughout the life course. By using a combination of universal programmes with general populations and specific offender-targeted programmes, a holistic approach can be achieved.

3 June 2019 in Journal of Interpersonal Violence
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
NTNeema Trivedi-Bateman
Neema Trivedi-Bateman
The roles of shame and guilt, and their relationships to empathy, have not been modeled adequately as key factors in moral decision-making in the study of violence. The role of moral emotion has been neglected in existing criminological research and this study seeks to develop current explanations of the comprehensive myriad of factors that play a role in moral crime decision-making. This research will test the different roles of empathy, shame, and guilt in violence decision-making using a situational action theory (SAT) perspective. Data taken from the Peterborough Adolescent and Young Adult Development Study (PADS+), a longitudinal study with a large representative sample, provide quantitative questionnaire indices to enable comparison of a persistent and frequent violent offender subsample ( N = 48) with the remaining PADS+ study sample ( N = 607). A striking majority of violent offenders report that they do not think it is wrong to commit violence, and do not care about it, that is, they lack shame and guilt, and report that violence comes as a morally acceptable and natural action alternative. Furthermore, violent offenders do not register the predicament of their victims; there is a distinct lack of empathy. This article demonstrates a key finding which has rarely been explored to date; regression analyses reveal an interaction effect whereby individuals with weak shame and guilt, combined specifically with weak moral rules, are more likely to commit acts of violence. The study findings provide strong support for the SAT of the role of weak morality in violence decision-making. To reduce the possibility of crime being seen as an action alternative, moral development programs should be developed and administered in childhood.

16 September 2023 in Journal of Research on Adolescence
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
NTNeema Trivedi-Bateman
Neema Trivedi-Bateman
AMAlison Jane Martingano
Alison Jane Martingano
We identify five challenges notoriously faced by researchers conducting youth intervention studies: access to the target population, successful recruitment, ensuring continued attendance, promoting engaged, enthused, and task‐focused participation, and efficient data collection. To ensure research quality, we have devised strategies to address these obstacles. Successes and lessons are included from The Compass Project (TCP), a 9‐week morality strengthening program designed to facilitate positive attitudinal and behavioral outcomes in young people. Despite four of the five identified challenges being overcome in TCP, the fifth challenge of data collection was insurmountable as many participants failed to complete questionnaire scales. We propose that researchers build on our success by building rapport and trust with participants and youth organizations and building a participant sense of community, and improve upon our design by scrutinizing the format, accessibility, and length of data measures. Ultimately, tests of whether intervention programs can result in positive outcomes in the lives of young people hinge on adequately overcoming the identified challenges. Implementation of the proposed strategies will be instrumental to allow for meaningful and powerful statistical analyses to more accurately gauge the positive impact of intervention programs on young people's lives.

3 August 2024 in European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
NTNeema Trivedi-Bateman
Neema Trivedi-Bateman
AMAnna Markovska
Anna Markovska
OSOleksii Serdiuk
Oleksii Serdiuk
RBRoman Bogdanov
Roman Bogdanov
Many anti-crime efforts are found to be costly and unsuccessful in reducing crime, and new fresh approaches are needed. Morality has long been neglected in our understanding of crime prevention. This paper uses a theoretical and empirical approach to explore the relationship between individual morality, associated moral emotions, and crime in a sample of 11,671 respondents in Ukraine. To date, few studies have explored morality using large samples in a Ukrainian context. Existing morality studies have been largely limited to nonadult and Global North samples. In the current study, existing standardised scales are applied for the first time in a new context. Morality is measured with how right or wrong respondents feel that various acts of delinquent and criminal behaviour are, and logistic regression is used to analyse its association with self-reported corruption, theft, and violence. Findings show that weak individual morality is associated with higher corruption, theft, and violence. This paper empirically evidences this association, already evidenced in The Global North, in an Eastern-European context. The implications of this are potentially wide-reaching and can inform crime prevention measures in Ukraine and beyond. Individual morality, which develops from early childhood and throughout adolescence, is associated with crime involvement in numerous studies and samples. To reduce crime, suggestions are made to deliver and evaluate morality intervention programmes (such as The Compass Project) in schools (to youth) and in the workplace (to influential employees of organisations and institutions). This is likely to contribute to a societal shift in countries like Ukraine which are presented with politically historic complexities in relation to morally acceptable actions.

29 September 2026 in CrimRxiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
PDF file
CHChristoph Herrmann
Christoph Herrmann
NTNeema Trivedi-Bateman
Neema Trivedi-Bateman
BHBeth Hardie
Beth Hardie
GRGabriela D. Roman
Gabriela D. Roman
The present study demonstrates the use and validity of the Virtual Reality Process Tracing Approach (VRPTA) using Situational Action Theory as a case study. It represents an innovative method combining immersive, high-fidelity filmed virtual reality (VR) scenarios, real-time decision-making, and process tracing to gain insight into decision processes. The scenario featured an opportunity to steal a £50 note. A total of 61 participants from the SATNAV:Compass programme, aged 11 to 14, were recruited from three schools in England. Results indicate that 3D, 180-degree VR scenarios successfully elicit real-time decision-making; participants found the scenarios realistic and reported a sense of presence, and their scenario responses have criterion-related validity (i.e., relationship with real-world behaviour). Participants’ reports about the extent to which crime was perceived as an alternative and whether it necessitated deliberation were validated using markers of deliberative choice: response times, decision confidence, and perceived difficulty. Independent-samples t-tests showed that those who reported deliberating about engaging in crime were slower to decide, were less confident in their decisions and found them more difficult to make. Furthermore, preliminary graphical and statistical analyses showed that whether participants perceived crime as the only action alternative, deliberated about it, or did not consider it at all, largely depended on their level of personal morality. This suggests that strong (law-relevant) personal morality acts as a filter for the perception of criminal action alternatives. At weaker levels, individuals were more likely to deliberate about stealing the money, in which case self-control and deterrence processes became relevant, whilst at the weakest levels they chose crime in a habitual manner. This novel use of immersive methods extends our understanding of cognitive decision-making processes beyond the classical input-output paradigm.

16 October 2026 in Social Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
NTNeema Trivedi-Bateman
Neema Trivedi-Bateman
BHBeth Hardie
Beth Hardie
MHMegan Huggett
Megan Huggett
Morality is central to explanations of youth rule-breaking, yet few interventions have systematically translated criminological theories of morality into theoretically specified, evidence-informed programmes. This report provides the first comprehensive account of SATNAV:Compass, a pioneering morality-focused intervention designed to promote positive youth development and reduce problem behaviour among adolescents. Grounded in Situational Action Theory and multidisciplinary evidence, the intervention translates theoretically specified mechanisms into four interconnected intervention strands: moral rules and emotions, empathy, emotion regulation, and self-control and peer resistance. SATNAV:Compass addresses each strand via evidence-based interactive small-group weekly activities. In this programme report, we present details of the implementation, process evaluation, and intended outcomes. Since 2023, SATNAV:Compass has been developed and iteratively refined across 15 trials in 9 schools with students aged 11–14. Across these trials, 2085 students completed initial screening with 602 selected for trial samples (308 programme, 294 control; 13 of the trials employed randomised controlled designs with crime-propensity-matched groups). Process evaluation findings demonstrate strong feasibility and acceptability and inform iterative programme refinement. Impact evaluation on key metrics is ongoing; early emerging indicators include increased intentions to apply learned strategies in rule-breaking situations, reduced social isolation, and improved relationships. Elsewhere, we have documented our approach and the development of the programme from conception to evaluation, establishing a transparent line of sight between theory, evidence, target causal factors, mechanisms of change, and programme content. This report summarises this development approach but focusses on establishing implementation foundations for rigorous evaluation and wider application of SATNAV:Compass in the UK and internationally. Combined, these outputs provide a rare and valuable model for future school-based interventions.