This study evaluated the effects of two different restorative assemblies and restorative material type on the fracture resistance of indirect composite restorations in simulated revitalized immature maxillary central incisors. Forty-eight extracted maxillary central incisors were randomly assigned to four groups (n = 12): breCAM.HIPC endocrowns, Gradia Plus endocrowns, breCAM.HIPC crowns, and Gradia Plus crowns. Following a standardized revitalization protocol, restorations were performed and specimens were thermocycled. Fracture resistance was assessed under oblique compressive loading, and fracture patterns were recorded. Data were analyzed using two-way ANOVA and Fisher’s exact test (α = 0.05). The tested restorative assembly significantly influenced fracture resistance (p < 0.05), whereas material type did not (p > 0.05). Endocrown restorations exhibited higher fracture resistance than crown restorations regardless of material. No statistically significant material-related differences were detected within the same restorative assembly. Crown restorations showed a higher incidence of coronal fractures. These findings indicate that, under the experimental conditions of this in vitro study, the tested endocrown restorations demonstrated higher fracture resistance than the Trinia core-supported crown restorations. However, because the two groups differed not only in restoration design but also in their internal structural configuration, including the use of fiber-reinforced composite cores only in the crown groups, the findings should be interpreted as reflecting the performance of the tested restorative assemblies rather than the isolated effect of restoration design.