A series of TiB2-Ni multilayer films with different Ni layer thicknesses was prepared by magnetron sputtering technology. The effect of Ni layer thickness on the microstructure and mechanical properties of the multilayer films was investigated, and the deformation and fracture mechanisms underlying the observed behavior were analyzed in detail. The results show that all multilayer films exhibit a well-defined layered architecture with sharp interfacial boundaries. Specifically, the Ni layers grow as columnar grains with an average diameter of approximately 10 nm, while the TiB2 layers form a very fine acicular nanocolumnar structure. With the increase in Ni layer thickness, the hardness of the multilayer films shows a decreasing trend, gradually decreasing from 27.3 GPa at a 4 nm Ni thickness to 19.3 GPa at 50 nm. In contrast, the fracture toughness increases gradually from 1.54 MPa·m1/2 to 2.73 MPa·m1/2. This enhancement in toughness is primarily attributed to a transition in the deformation and fracture mechanism. With the increase in Ni layer thickness, the crack propagation mode in the multilayer films gradually changes from the integral propagation penetrating the film layers to the crack deflection propagation within the layers. This transformation is the result of the combined effect of the stress state of each layer and the crack energy dissipation.