Low ice adhesion surfaces are a promising anti-icing strategy. However, experimentally obtained ice adhesion strengths are so far not transferable or comparable, and they are very sensitive to the experimental set-up and type of accreted ice. This critical review describes both the widely used ice adhesion measurement techniques and ice generation methods, before discussing why the results cannot be directly compared. The ice adhesion measurement techniques included are horizontal and vertical shear tests, centrifugal ice adhesion tests and tensile tests. The ice generation methods included in the review are icing by freezing drizzle, wind tunnel icing and bulk water icing, and definitions of other ice types are included. Special challenges for low ice adhesion surfaces have been discussed, as well as the effect of ice sample size and the impact from gravity. A future standard within ice adhesion research should be able to directly compare different experimental results, and should, therefore, include all relevant parameters and currently available methods. Due to the large variation of available ice adhesion set-ups, it is recommended that a reference test and ice type is established for enhanced comparability. The reference suggested is a horizontal shear test with bulk water ice, and defined experimental parameters. A continuing focus on the fundamental mechanisms of ice adhesion is needed to identify the important contributions to the large variations in reported ice adhesion strengths.
Low ice adhesion surfaces are a promising anti-icing strategy. However, reported ice adhesion strengths cannot be directly compared between research groups. This study compares results obtained from testing the ice adhesion strength on two types of surfaces at two different laboratories, testing two different types of ice with different ice adhesion test methods at temperatures of −10 and −18 °C. One laboratory used the centrifuge adhesion test and tested precipitation ice and bulk water ice, while the other laboratory used a vertical shear test and tested only bulk water ice. The surfaces tested were bare aluminum and a commercial icephobic coating, with all samples prepared in the same manner. The results showed comparability in the general trends, surprisingly, with the greatest differences for bare aluminum surfaces at −10 °C. For bulk water ice, the vertical shear test resulted in systematically higher ice adhesion strength than the centrifugal adhesion test. The standard deviation depends on the surface type and seems to scale with the absolute value of the ice adhesion strength. The experiments capture the overall trends in which the ice adhesion strength surprisingly decreases from −10 to −18 °C for aluminum and is almost independent of temperature for a commercial icephobic coating. In addition, the study captures similar trends in the effect of ice type on ice adhesion strength as previously reported and substantiates that ice formation is a key parameter for ice adhesion mechanisms. Repeatability should be considered a key parameter in determining the ideal ice adhesion test method.
The limited durability of slippery lubricant-infused porous surfaces (SLIPS) restricts their practical applications. Inspired by the epidermal glands of skins, we developed a facile approach to durable SLIPS with gland-like storage and release functions for icephobicity. By introducing a hybrid surfactant as a lubricant into the polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) matrix, lubricant capsules were formed and mono-dispersed in the matrix, working as gland-like structures to release lubricant. The obtained SLIPS showed durable low ice adhesion strength and thermal durability simultaneously. In detail, the enhanced durability for icephobicity was demonstrated by 20 icing/deicing tests, in which the lubricant remains on the surface; the coatings showed negligible weight loss when stored at 100 °C for 60 h, displaying pronounced thermal durability of the slippery effect. Our current strategy sheds new light on a facile fabrication of mechanically and thermally durable SLIPS for icephobicity.
Surfaces with low ice adhesion represent a promising strategy to achieve passive anti-icing performance. However, as a successful and robust low ice adhesion surface must be tested under realistic conditions at low temperatures and for several types of ice, the initial screening of potential low ice adhesion surfaces requires large resources. A theoretical relation between ice adhesion and water wettability in the form of water contact angle exists, but there is disagreement on whether this relation holds for experiments. In this study, we utilised molecular dynamics simulations to examine the fundamental relations between ice adhesion and water contact angle on an ideal graphene surface. The results show a significant correlation according to the theoretic predictions, indicating that the theoretical relation holds for the ice and water when discarding surface material deformations and other experimental factors. The reproduction of the thermodynamic theory at the nanoscale is important due to the gap between experimental observations and theoretical models. The results in this study represent a step forward towards understanding the fundamental mechanisms of water–solid and ice–solid interactions, and the relationship between them.
12 October 2020 in Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology
For decades, there has been no proper thermodynamic definition of icephobicity. Some claim icephobic properties at an adhesion lower than 100 kPa, whereas others claim it when the accretion of ice is significantly prolonged. Herein we propose to use a terminology based on the type of frozen water deposition and its physical behaviour, separating ice and snow in adhesion and accretion. This is done in order to lay a foundation on which to introduce a framework for classification of snow- and icephobic surfaces. Such a classification empowers users and producers of such surfaces to communicate accurately about performances and expectations of surfaces and coatings. We include snowphobicity in this scheme, as snow is closely related to the traditional icephobicity and often exhibit overlapping requirements.
29 September 2023 in IEEE Journal of Photovoltaics
Owing to the well-known temperature dependence of photovoltaic (PV) module performance, it is important to correct the performance ratio with respect to temperature. In this study, temperature coefficients given by the manufacturer for three different PV cell technologies are compared with experimentally obtained temperature coefficients for a PV park situated in southern Norway. Three irradiance estimation methods are used to calculate these experimental temperature coefficients. The results show that they can differ significantly from the ones provided in the datasheet of the manufacturer for all three PV systems, but whether the temperature coefficient value increases or decreases depends on the systems and/or the irradiance estimation method. Furthermore, by analyzing nine clear sky days at different times of the year, it is found that the seasonality of the performance ratio can be significantly reduced when employing the experimental temperature coefficient rather than the datasheet temperature coefficient. As such, it may be more relevant to correct the performance ratio with experimental temperature coefficients rather than with the temperature coefficient from the system datasheet, especially for systems that experience large temperature differences. It is also found that the irradiance estimation method can significantly impact the experimental temperature coefficient. This study shows that the choice of irradiance estimation method and temperature coefficient can affect the performance interpretation of solar PV systems and must then be considered carefully.