The integration of renewable energy sources (RES) is essential for steering our energy systems towards sustainability. This transition, though, coupled with emerging trends such as digitalisation and decentralisation, introduces a number of new challenges and vulnerabilities to our energy infrastructure. To strengthen our energy systems against the uncertainties arising from intermittent RES and decentral organised power grids, battery energy storage systems (BESSs) integrated into sector‐coupling strategies might play a crucial role. Such BESSs can enhance system resilience by providing increased flexibility in the face of disruptive events. Yet, the assessment of their resilience contribution is still a nascent field, particularly within the context of multi‐energy systems. To address this gap, our study presents an assessment scheme utilising the open source energy system model electricity grid optimisation. We apply this scheme to evaluate the impact of sector‐coupled BESS installations with a local district heating network in a mid‐sized German city. Our analysis encompasses various scenarios, considering diverse BESS sizes, quantities, seasonal influences, system scales, siting, and the severity of disruptive events. The principal findings are threefold: for energy systems that exhibit high inherent robustness, such as those with existing adaptive capacities and redundancies, hybrid BESS (hBESS) has a low impact on the resilience against single disruptive events. In contrast, for less prepared systems or during simultaneous events, hBESSs can substantially strengthen the resilience of the energy infrastructure, particularly regarding the ‘security of supply’ and ‘cost efficiency’. For instance, during short‐lasting disruptive events, hBESS can potentially avert up potential power outages from 1.4% to 45% increasing the security of supply. However, the resilient design principle ‘spatial diversity’ could not improve the system’s resilience in all scenarios. This holistic approach is essential for identifying resilient strategies capable of effectively countering unforeseen disruptive events, thereby ensuring the continued stability and sustainability of our energy systems.
The energy transition and associated objectives like climate change mitigation, economic efficiency, social acceptance and security of supply require technologies that are sustainable. With the help of a Life Cycle Sustainability Assessment (LCSA), such a holistic evaluation of energy technologies can be carried out. This in itself is very complex, since criteria of the different sustainability dimensions have to be compiled and integrated to give an overall result. However, LCSA often only considers the current development status of technologies and not their potential future developments. Particularly in the case of emerging technologies, possible future improvements or even negative impacts may occur in the course of technology development, which could significantly change the initial LCSA results. An early consideration of future developments of technologies in the context of so-called prospective LCSA is therefore highly relevant, but also of high complexity and associated with uncertainties. We evaluated how this complex topic of prospectivity has been dealt with in the LCSA community so far by conducting a literature review. Focusing on LCSA of energy technologies, we present our findings related to commonly used prospective methods and data, the underling motivation of their application as well as research gaps and potentials for further development.
Indicators are crucial for any management as they allow for monitoring, reviewing and adapting strategies towards a previously planned objective. The key challenge for fulfilling this task is to identify and define indicators that enable the assessment of the system under consideration. Regarding energy systems, if understood as complex socio-technical systems, a multitude of indicators for resilience assessments have been proposed, which vary according to the different systems analysed as well as indicators and stakeholder requirements. Hence, it seems that universal indicator frameworks are not applicable for resilience assessments and thus specific indicators are needed. However, a crucial step towards developing a general resilience assessment and monitoring framework is to understand on which aspects indicators depend, what “good” indicators can cover and what the limits of these indicators are. Therefore, this chapter gives an insight into the general characteristics of indicators. Then, it describes the indicator requirements particularly with respect to the resilience (monitoring) for energy systems. Furthermore, the chapter will address some specifics for the resilience assessment and management of energy systems based on some exemplary indicators.