This paper presents an analogy between micro-hydroelectric and small wind energy conversion systems, validating two commonly used power extraction methods. Although the paper focuses on the Pelton hydroelectric turbine, most of the analysis, methods, and results could also be extended to other types of hydroelectric turbines. First, the physical model of the Pelton turbine is described, and then it is adapted to the modeling methods applied to wind turbines. This shows the analogy between the models of Pelton and wind turbines. Based on this analogy, two simple and effective maximum power extraction methods developed for small wind turbines are applied to micro-hydroelectric power generation by Pelton turbines. The first tested method is the model-based maximum power point tracking (MPPT) algorithm, which is based on indirect speed control. This method effectively maximizes the power generation of the hydraulic turbine by using a simple power electronics conversion system. It minimizes the complexity and computational cost of the algorithm and requires few electric magnitude measurements. Thus, the necessity of using a position or speed sensor is avoided (sensorless). After that, the so called Pseudo-MPPT method is tested, which further simplifies the power conversion system, eliminates the necessity of a micro-processor and therefore, also avoids the use of sensors. Experimental validation of both maximum power extraction methods show that they effectively maximize the power generation of Pelton turbines, under both constant and variable flow rate conditions. Thus, while the MPPT method tends to extract more power than the Pseudo-MPPT method at constant flow rates, the Pseudo-MPPT method can be designed to be nearly as efficient as the MPPT method in contexts where the flow rate is well-defined and limited to a known range. It should be noted, however, that the Pseudo-MPPT method has a very fast dynamic response time to adapt to flow rate variations, and its simplicity makes it attractive in terms of practical implementation, low cost, and reduced design and commissioning complexity for engineers, as well as good reliability due to its minimized component needs. To conclude, several application scenarios for these micro-hydroelectric turbines are presented and described in detail.