This study aims to establish an effective approach for evaluating the safety performance of road infrastructure. Road safety levels are typically quantified using safety performance indicators. However, due to the stochastic nature of accidents, many safety performance indicators cannot adequately and completely describe reality. Therefore, predictive methods based on regression models are widely used. This approach also allows for the identification of latent risk conditions in the infrastructure, even in the absence of accidents. Among available approaches, the Highway Safety Manual (HSM) methodology is chosen for its synthesis of validated highway research and best practices for incorporating safety into both new design and rehabilitation. For this study, a preliminary new version of HSM is used. The application of this method, which combines a predictive model with observed accidents through an empirical Bayesian approach, requires a calibration process that is crucial to tailoring this method to the specific study context. In this research, the predictive model is calibrated for single carriageway roads with one lane per direction across the Italian national network. Following calibration, the safety indicators are evaluated. The results obtained according to different indicators are compared to show the importance of adopting this method to counteract the regression to the mean of observed crashes. In fact, the method, supported by empirical Bayesian analysis, enables the identification of high-risk sections of the road network, selecting more sections that would be neglected by traditional indicators based solely on observed crashes. Finally, a possible approach to prioritizing sites for inspection based both on the excess of crashes and the Safety Potential (SAPO) is proposed. In addition, SAPO is adjusted to local conditions to account for the specific context and the decreasing trend of accidents over the years.
The purpose of this study is to determine the safety effectiveness of an intervention on an existing road by using predictive methods. Predictive methods allow the benefit of the intervention to be quantified in terms of crash reduction. Currently, the most widely used model is reported in the Highway Safety Manual, developed in the US. The HSM model is adapted to the Italian context through a calibration procedure. The model is then applied to two future scenarios: in the absence and presence of intervention. The redesign intervention consists of rehabilitating some road sections and constructing five tunnel bypasses to avoid crossing residential areas. The comparison between the ‘with’ and ‘without’ scenario estimated an overall reduction in the number of accidents of around 45%. The variant scenario is based on reasonable assumptions that allowed the determination of the proportion of traffic that will be diverted to the variant. In addition, several alternative future scenarios are considered to assess a possible different trend in assumed traffic distribution. Moreover, a possible overall increase or reduction in total traffic affecting the road is taken into account. The results showed that the intervention provided significant benefits even with increased traffic, proving the resilience of the intervention.
In this paper, the effectiveness of reinforcements for flexible pavements is evaluated through an analysis of reflective cracking. Different stiffness and thickness reinforcements are considered for the rehabilitation of an already cracked pavement. The effect of the reinforcement is assessed from two different perspectives: (i) the ability to reduce stresses in the rehabilitated pavement layers, and (ii) the capacity to mitigate the crack propagation from deeper layers. A finite element model (FEM) is adopted to study the stress and strain state of the pavement layers. The pavement model has been properly validated, transitioning from a simply supported beam scheme to an elastic multilayer model. In addition, to represent crack propagation, fracture evolution is analyzed using Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics (LEFMs) and Paris’ law. The effect of different reinforcements on the pavement is then simulated. The results show that the reinforcement performance is strictly dependent on the interlayer thickness and stiffness. In particular, high stiffness reinforcements (geomembranes) show increasing effectiveness with stiffness, both in terms of reflective cracking and stress reduction. Conversely, low stiffness reinforcements (SAMIs) show a variable trend with the stiffness modulus. In fact, extremely low stiffness is effective in slowing down crack propagation but is detrimental to the wearing course’s stress condition. However, as the stiffness increases, the likelihood of cracking in the wearing course decreases, though only a small beneficial effect is registered for crack propagation in the base layer.
This study is focused on safety aspects related to the use of e-scooters in urban areas. Since e-scooters recently appeared in urban areas, rapidly spreading, and increasing in popularity, several Countries and Municipalities have been not able to properly update both legislation and infrastructure. In fact, many of the enacted rules have been temporary and repeatedly modified, causing confusion among users. Moreover, road pavements are mostly inappropriate to e-scooters, equipped with small wheels and with serious stability issues, especially during braking. As a result, recently, a significant number of e-scooter-related accidents occurred, raising attention to the road-safety topic. These are the reasons why the preliminary investigation reported in this study is devoted to understanding typical user behaviors and the overall safety perception connected to these vehicles. In detail, the study is focused on three main points: (i) the Italian citizens’ opinion on e-scooters’ effects on urban mobility safety, by submitting an on-line questionnaire to collect opinions from both users and non-users of e-scooters; (ii) the e-scooter users behavior, by performing on-site surveys aimed at achieving a direct observation of the phenomenon in Milan (Italy); (iii) the e-scooters-pavement interaction by means field tests carried out installing an accelerometer on an e-scooter and measuring the vibration effects deriving from different pavement types and distresses. The preliminary results reported in the paper demonstrate the different safety perception of e-scooters users and non-users, some critical aspects related to e-scooters drivers’ behavior, non-negligible safety effects arising from pavement-e-scooter interaction as consequence of pavement type and condition and e-scooter's speed.