This study compares characteristics and implications for sustainable resource management of supergene and primary mineral deposits. Supergene deposits, formed through weathering and oxidation near the Earth’s surface, represent a significant source of critical and industrial metals. The increasing demand and rising prices for these materials have heightened interest in supergene deposits due to their potential for low-cost production. Supergene deposits are superficial, have lower stripping ratios, and exhibit greater rock friability, potentially requiring less investment while providing substantial returns, even considering their relatively low grades. These characteristics lead to reduced energy consumption, smaller carbon footprints, and fewer acid and solubilizing compounds due to the absence of sulfides. However, processing supergene ore can require significant freshwater resources, especially for clay-rich ores that consume larger amounts of non-recoverable water and large surface footprints relevant to local communities and land rehabilitation. Most supergene deposits are in emerging countries, where mining practices are crucial for development. Some commodities, such as gold and cobalt in supergene deposits, attract artisanal and small-scale miners, often presenting challenges to ensure worker safety and abolish child labor. The global production of critical minerals faces market tensions due to monopolies, limited economic deposits worldwide, and trade restrictions, compromising supply security. The discovery and characterization of new deposits, to diversify supply sources, are essential to mitigate market concentration risks and enhance supply chain resilience, contributing to overall market stability. We demonstrate the importance of reviewing supergene ore deposit models with the Environment, Social, and Governance (ESG) lens to establish foundations for informed decision-making, and sustainable and responsible extraction and processing.