Mass unbalance is one of the most prominent faults that occurs in rotating machines. The identification of unbalance in the case of large flexible rotors is crucial because in industrial applications such as paper machines and roll grinders, high vibrations can adversely affect the quality of the end product. The objective of this research is to determine the unbalance location, magnitude and phase for a large flexible rotor with few measured coordinates. To this end, an established force-based method comprising of modal expansion and equivalent load minimization is applied. Due to the anisotropic behavior of the test rotor, the force method required at least six measured coordinates to predict the unbalance with an error of 4 to 36%. To overcome this limitation, an alternate method, eliminating the use of modal expansion, is proposed. Here, displacements generated by varying the location of a reference unbalance along the rotor axis, are compared to measured displacements to detect the unbalance location. Furthermore, instead of force-based fault models, the minimization of displacements at measured locations determines the unbalance parameters. The test case in this study is the guiding roll of a paper machine and its different unbalance states. The algorithm is tested initially with a simulation-based model and then validated with an experimental set up. The results show that the displacement method can locate the unbalance close to the actual location and it can predict the unbalance magnitude and phase with only two measured coordinates. Lastly, using measured data from 15 measurement points across the tube section of the test rotor, a comparison shows how the selection of the two measured locations affects the estimation accuracy.
Vibration problems have been observed after the installation of large rotating machines, such as electric machines and generators and paper machine rolls. One possible cause can be differences between the foundation stiffness of the installation location and the testing platform where the machine is balanced and optimized. Foundation stiffness exerts a significant effect on the behavior of a rotating system, and the above-mentioned differences can cause major unexpected changes at natural frequencies, and thus resonance. The problem is typical for large machines due to their large mass, which leads to low natural frequencies. This induces situations where these natural frequencies coincide with rotor excitations and cause excessive vibration. This study presents a novel method and a device for adjusting the foundation stiffness of a large rotor system, consequently enabling the investigation of the effect of foundation stiffness on rotor behavior. However, this investigation is restricted to the horizontal axis. The characteristics of the device were analyzed together with a rotor behavior measurement that consisted of versatile measurements of acceleration, force and displacement in different locations inside the rotating system. The device in the presented form is best applied in R&D laboratories and factory acceptance test cells, in which it can be used to predict the behavior of various rotors on different foundations. With the dynamic rotor behavior measurement performed with the device, the natural frequencies and their harmonic components can be presented as a function of foundation stiffness. This information can be used both to optimize rotor behavior in an installation location and also to improve the rotor system behavior in the design phase. The method and device presented in this study can be considered effective and successful, since the natural frequencies of the first two rotor modes could be manipulated freely at a range of 50-100 % by changing the stiffness.
Bending stiffness variation (BSV) is a common problem causing vibration in large rotating machinery. BSV describes lateral bending stiffness and its variation as a function of the rotational angle. It has been observed that BSV causes excitation exactly twice per revolution, which leads to vibration problems, especially at half critical speed. BSV is caused by rotor geometry errors if the material is assumed to be homogeneous and linearly elastic. Therefore, the study investigated BSV with harmonic roundness components, which are commonly used in industry to describe the geometry of a rotor. Hence, the results are easily applicable in the industry. The research was conducted primarily by analytical means, but also static simulations and numeric calculations were used. The results clearly showed that when the effect of single harmonic roundness components in rotor cross-sections were observed, only the second component could produce BSV. However, when component pairs were studied, they produced BSV also without the second component. If the second component was included, the profile produced BSV the most aggressively. A generated arbitrary roundness profile, including components 3–50 with random phases and amplitudes, indicated that BSV occurs always twice per revolution despite different components in the profile. The results improve the possibilities of eliminating excessive BSV in the industry, when certain components and component pairs can be avoided.
8 December 2021 in Bulletin Of The Polish Academy Of Sciences-Technical Sciences
To achieve acceptable dynamical behavior for large rotating machines operating at subcritical speeds, the balancing quality check at the planned service speed in the installation location is often demanded for machines such as turbo-generators or high-speed machines. While most studies investigate the balancing quality at critical speeds, only a few studies have investigated this aspect using numerical methods at operational speed. This study proposes a novel, model-based method for inversely estimating initial residual unbalance in one and two planes after initial grade balancing for large flexible rotors operating at the service speeds. The method utilizes vibration measurements from two planes in any single direction, combined with a finite element model of the rotor to inversely determine the residual unbalance in one and two planes. This method can be practically used to determine the initial and residual unbalance after the balancing process, and further it can be used for condition-based monitoring of the unbalance state of the rotor.